Apple to face Paris trial in 2027 over iPhone repair limits

Apple will stand trial before the Paris criminal court in 2027 over allegations that it deliberately blocked independent repairs of iPhones, after French prosecutors decided to pursue the case. The announcement was made on 17 November 2026 by the French consumer group Halte à l'Obsolescence Programmée, known as HOP, which filed the original complaint in December 2022.
The case will be heard by the Paris tribunal correctionnel, France's criminal court for offences of this kind. A first procedural hearing is set for 25 February 2027 to settle the timetable, with the trial itself expected to run over several days in June 2027. Apple has rejected the allegations. A company spokesperson told Agence France-Presse: "We strongly contest these unfounded allegations." No court has yet ruled on the claims.
What Apple is accused of
At the centre of the case is a practice known as serialization, or parts pairing. HOP says Apple links the serial numbers of iPhone components — including screens, batteries, cameras and some biometric sensors — to the individual phone's logic board. When an independent technician replaces one of those parts, the phone can flag the part or restrict its functions unless the replacement is validated through Apple's own system.
Prosecutors say this obstructed the repair and refurbishment of iPhones outside Apple's authorised network for more than two and a half years. The proceedings cover 24 iPhone models sold between 17 November 2021 and 23 July 2024, and rest on Article L441-3 of the French Consumer Code, which has barred techniques — including software — that stop repair outside a manufacturer's approved channels since 2021.
A first for France's repair law
HOP says the case is the first prosecution in France under the offence of obstructing repair and refurbishment, and has called it a strong signal for consumers. The group first complained on 7 December 2022, and an investigation began in May 2023. Apple launched its self-service repair programme in France on 6 December 2022, the day before HOP filed its complaint, but the group argues the programme still limits repairs to authorised parts and channels.
Apple's last French case of this kind ended differently: an inquiry into iPhones slowed by software updates closed in 2020 with a €25 million fine in a criminal settlement, without a trial. This time, prosecutors have taken the settlement option off the table and sent the company to court.
Why the case matters beyond France
The outcome could shape how far manufacturers can tie spare parts to a specific device, a practice repair advocates say pushes consumers towards expensive official repairs or new phones. Similar right-to-repair rules are being debated across Europe and in several US states, so a Paris ruling on parts pairing would be watched well beyond France. For now, though, the allegations remain unproven, and Apple will have its chance to answer them in court next year.
The prosecution was first reported by AppleInsider, and the planned trial was independently reported by Euronews with Agence France-Presse, as covered by EuropeSays. HOP's own announcement is on the HOP website.
Frequently asked questions
When is the Apple trial in Paris? A first hearing is set for 25 February 2027, with the trial expected over several days in June 2027.
What is iPhone parts pairing? It is the practice of linking a component's serial number to a specific iPhone, so a replacement part may be flagged or restricted unless validated through Apple's system.
Has Apple been found guilty? No. The allegations have not been ruled on by any court, and Apple strongly contests them.