BJ's beats forecasts but shares fall 7% on $240m wrinkle

BJ's Wholesale Club beat third-quarter forecasts and raised its full-year outlook on Friday, but its shares fell 7.1% in premarket trading after investors focused on a one-off legal settlement that flattered the results.
The warehouse-club retailer reported adjusted earnings of $1.73 a share, well above the $1.26 consensus estimate, according to FactSet. Revenue grew 18% to $6.28 billion, beating Wall Street's call for $5.97 billion.
The results included a roughly $240 million benefit from a settlement of litigation over credit-card interchange fees, BJ's said, partly offset by $95 million in related expenses. The company disclosed the settlement in September and said the pretax benefit would be reflected in its third-quarter results.
Outlook raised despite the fall
BJ's raised its fiscal-year adjusted earnings outlook to $5.10 to $5.30 a share, up from a previous forecast of $4.60 to $4.80. Analysts had expected earnings of $4.74.
Underlying trading was strong. Comparable club sales, excluding petrol, increased 4.1% from a year earlier, accelerating from 3.1% in the previous quarter and beating expectations for 2.9% growth. Membership fee income rose 9.5% year over year to $138.4 million, above expectations for $136.2 million, which the company attributed to strong member acquisition and retention and increased adoption of its higher-priced membership tiers.
But that growth came with added costs. BJ's merchandise gross margin declined about 170 basis points from a year ago, which the company said reflected promotional spending tied to its 42nd birthday celebration.
Shares head for biggest drop since May
Shares of BJ's fell 7.1% to $102.85 in premarket trading on Friday. If the decline holds, it would be the stock's largest daily percentage decrease since May, according to Dow Jones Market Data. Shares have risen 17% since Barron's recommended them in January.
BJ's warehouse-club model has resonated with cost-conscious consumers as elevated prices continue to squeeze household budgets. Rival Costco Wholesale has benefited from the same demand for discounted groceries and everyday essentials, reporting an 8.1% increase in US comparable sales in October, excluding the impact of petrol price changes.
Other retailers reported strong sales this week as consumers sought value. Walmart reported a 2.9% increase in comparable sales, excluding fuel, while its Sam's Club chain posted 4.9% growth. Target reported a 5.6% increase, while off-price retailer TJX, which owns T.J. Maxx and Marshalls, reported 4% growth.
Those stronger sales have not necessarily translated into higher margins. TJX reported a 50-basis-point decline in adjusted gross margin, reflecting higher freight and fuel costs. Target cited transport costs and investments in lower prices as pressures on profitability, although its underlying gross margin improved.
Sources: Barron's; BJ's Wholesale Club Holdings press release.