'Crypto King' secret audio aired in kidnap trial

A secret audio recording played to a Toronto jury on Friday has become the latest flashpoint in the trial of three men accused of kidnapping Aiden Pleterski, the self-described "Crypto King" convicted of fraud last month over tens of millions of dollars taken from investors.
Defence lawyer Leora Shemesh, who represents Alfredo Paladino, told the Ontario Superior Court that Pleterski sounded "cool and collected" in the recording, which she said was made by his alleged kidnappers. In it, Pleterski discusses the value of luxury watches, gold bars and cars he says his former landlord, hotel executive Sandeep Gupta, is hiding for him. "This is the plan and a roadmap of how this kidnapping is going to play out," Shemesh told Pleterski during cross-examination. "You are directing these men how you're going to do it and how you're going to sell it."
Shemesh suggested the recording had been made as an "insurance policy" to show that the kidnapping was a hoax. A day earlier, she had called the alleged abduction a "farce", alleging that Pleterski created a video pretending to be kidnapped in order to win sympathy from the investors who were trying to recover their money from him.
Pleterski denies faking his abduction
Pleterski, 28, denied the claim. He testified that the recording was made after he had been kidnapped and after an initial beating, and before a so-called confession video. He said he lied about Gupta hiding assets in order to convince his captors that they needed an in-person meeting with Gupta, at which he hoped to escape.
"I know it was taken before the confession video and it was taken after the initial beating," Pleterski told the jury. Shemesh completed her cross-examination on Friday. Pleterski, who has been testifying all week, is expected back in the witness box on Monday for a third cross-examination, this time by the lawyer for another accused man, Rakeem Henry.
The case against the three men
Paladino, Henry and Akil Heywood are on trial over the alleged abduction of Pleterski in December 2022. The Crown alleges the then 23-year-old trader was seized in downtown Toronto on 5 December and held for three days, during which he was beaten with weapons, waterboarded, burned with cigarettes and had a gun fired twice beside his head, while his captors demanded millions of dollars to cover lost investments. All three men have pleaded not guilty to kidnapping, forcible confinement and extortion.
Pleterski has told the jury he was zip-tied and taped to a chair in a run-down house in the Niagara Region, and was then left in the care of a couple who he said had been paid 5,000 dollars to keep him there. He said he offered the couple between 50,000 and 100,000 dollars to release him and put them up in a downtown Toronto hotel. During a drive back toward Toronto, he said, a man he knew as "Slime" told him to get his assets from Gupta, warning that his family would be killed if he did not.
Gupta, the president of the Sunray Group of Hotels, was the prosecution's first witness when the trial opened on 10 November. He told the court that Pleterski called him repeatedly just after midnight on 6 December 2022, urgently asking for two to three million dollars. Although Pleterski never said outright that he had been kidnapped, Gupta said his voice sounded distressed and unnatural, and he used his wife's phone to call 911 while keeping Pleterski on the line. An officer later found Pleterski in a hotel lobby near the Ritz-Carlton.
Fraud conviction hangs over the trial
The kidnapping trial is unfolding only weeks after a separate Toronto jury found Pleterski guilty of fraud for running an investment scheme that took more than 30 million dollars from hundreds of people. He has not yet been sentenced in that case. The fraud conviction is central to the defence argument: his alleged kidnappers say the men who seized him were investors trying to recover money he had lost, and that the supposed abduction was staged.
For the Crown, the case turns on the violence Pleterski says he suffered and the three days he spent in captivity. For the defence, it turns on whether the jury believes the recordings, the videos and Pleterski's own shifting accounts. With two more cross-examinations still to come, the trial is set to test the credibility of a witness who is himself a convicted fraudster - and whose story, on either version, is extraordinary.
Sources: CBC News; IBY News; The Canada Report.