DEUTZ Rejects NINGI Short-Seller FFG Claims

German engine maker DEUTZ has hit back at short seller NINGI Research, rejecting the key conclusions of its report on the company's €1.6 billion acquisition of Flensburger Fahrzeugbau Gesellschaft (FFG) as unfounded. The Cologne-based group issued its rebuttal on Thursday, a day after the short seller's allegations were published, and used the same statement to reaffirm its defence targets for 2027.
DEUTZ announced the takeover of FFG, a maker of armoured vehicles, in July 2026 and completed the deal in early November, paying partly in new shares. The acquisition is the centrepiece of the group's push into defence, a business it wants to build into a key pillar alongside energy, engines, new technology and services. NINGI, which has said it is betting on a falling DEUTZ share price, argues the price was too high and has questioned the disclosure around the deal and the way profits are shared inside FFG Industries, the holding company beneath it.
What the short seller claimed
At the heart of NINGI's case is the ownership structure of FFG Industries. The short seller says a 45 per cent stake is held by former Ukrainian parliamentarian Maksym Yefimov, and argues that this minority holder could block distributions and key decisions. On that reading, NINGI contends that DEUTZ cannot fully consolidate FFG Industries in its accounts and should instead treat it as a joint venture, accounted for under the equity method.
The accounting point matters because it changes the headline numbers. Under NINGI's scenario, treating FFG Industries as a joint venture would leave 2027 revenue €546 million lower and earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation €109 million lower than DEUTZ has indicated. Those are the short seller's own estimates, not figures reported by DEUTZ, and they go to the credibility of the defence growth story on which the deal was sold to investors.
How DEUTZ answered
DEUTZ rejected the central conclusions point by point. The company said only the portion of FFG Industries attributable to FFG itself was fed into the valuation, so the €1.6 billion price was calculated on the right basis, and that an independent valuation and a review of the price's financial adequacy supported it. On the accounting question, it said an expert assessment by independent auditors supported full consolidation of FFG Industries under international accounting standards.
On governance, DEUTZ said the minority shareholders of FFG Industries had expressly and irrevocably consented to the acquisition and waived their rights in the event of a change of control, answering the claim that a minority holder could force it out on unfavourable terms. It added that FFG Industries' liquidity was available to the group through standard market instruments for liquidity management, and that partnership structures of this kind are customary in the defence sector. The company also noted that NINGI held a short position in DEUTZ shares when it published its report.
Orders keep coming
DEUTZ backed its rebuttal with trading evidence. FFG's order backlog has risen to more than €2.7 billion since the acquisition was announced in July, and the group confirmed its targets of at least €1 billion in defence revenue and an adjusted EBITDA margin of at least 20 per cent in 2027. Fresh business arrived this week as well, with the Dutch procurement agency COMMIT placing follow-on orders with FFG covering ACSV vehicles and WiSENT-2 recovery tanks.
Investors appear to have taken the rebuttal in their stride. After heavy pressure earlier in the week, DEUTZ shares recovered ground in Friday trading, changing hands at €7.70 on Lang & Schwarz at 18:30 CET. The dispute is unlikely to end here, since NINGI's challenge rests on legal and accounting judgements that only time and audited results can settle. But DEUTZ has now put a detailed defence on the record, and the order book, rather than the argument, will be the test of whether the FFG bet pays off.
Sources: ad-hoc-news | Newsquawk