Dutch court bars BYD Ti7 sales across the EU

A Dutch court has barred Chinese carmaker BYD from selling its Ti7 SUV in the European Union, ruling that the vehicle infringes the design of Jaguar Land Rover's Defender. The decision, handed down by a judge at the district court in The Hague on Friday, is an early but significant victory for JLR in a dispute that has already seen bailiffs raid BYD offices in the Netherlands.
The court imposed a temporary injunction prohibiting BYD from selling the Ti7 anywhere in the EU. The injunction takes effect a week after the ruling, the court said, because BYD currently has no concrete plans to put the vehicle on sale in the bloc. The judge also ruled that the court had no jurisdiction over BYD's affiliate in the United Kingdom, leaving JLR to pursue that part of the case in the British courts.
What the court decided
In summary proceedings, the preliminary relief judge found that the Ti7 reflects the characteristic and distinctive elements of the Defender's registered EU design. The ruling covers all 27 EU member states and bars the import, production, offering for sale, sale, storage and delivery of the Ti7. Until the underlying intellectual property case is resolved, the court also banned BYD from producing the vehicle at its new factory in Hungary, which is due to start mass-producing cars early next year.
The judge identified six elements that define the Defender's design: its shoulders with rounded corners, the wheel-arch cut-outs, the continuous glasshouse, the signature panel, the car's proportions and its overall silhouette. JLR, a unit of India's Tata Motors, launched the case earlier this year after BYD announced on its UK website that the seven-seater Ti7 was available for orders, with deliveries to customers starting in January 2027. BYD launched the Fangchengbao Ti7 in China last year.
The Ti7 had been nicknamed the "copycat Defender" by commentators because of its resemblance to JLR's bestselling model. It was due to make its debut in Britain with prices starting at £47,995, about £20,000 less than the cheapest Defender. The Defender is JLR's most popular model, with global sales of more than 100,000 units in 2025.
A rare design fight between carmakers
It is rare in Europe for major carmakers to go to court over design rights, and uncommon for such a ruling to come so early in proceedings in a case that is ongoing and likely to last for some time. Legacy carmakers have often complained that Chinese rivals copy their designs, though little has been proven in court. In 2005, for instance, General Motors and Chinese rival Chery settled a case over the Chery QQ, which the American carmaker said was a copy of its Chevrolet Spark.
The dispute escalated over the summer, when representatives of JLR raided BYD's Dutch offices in Schiedam and Hoofddorp to seize digital assets. Last week the same Dutch court ordered JLR to return the files its bailiffs had seized, although sources close to the carmaker treated that as a victory because it confirmed the Ti7 would be launched outside China.
BYD's rapid rise in Europe
The ruling lands as BYD is expanding fast in Europe. The company began selling cars on the continent in late 2022, and according to ACEA industry data its sales in Europe more than doubled this year through September to over 280,000 vehicles, outselling Ford, Tesla and Nissan over the same period.
That growth has made BYD the most prominent Chinese challenger to Europe's established carmakers, and the Ti7 was set to be one of its most important launches in the region. A ban on producing the model at its Hungarian plant, if it stands, would complicate those plans well beyond the showroom.
What happens next
BYD said it strongly disagrees with the ruling and will appeal. "The BYD Ti7 is the result of BYD's own independent design work and infringes none of JLR's rights," the company said. "We will pursue every legal avenue to demonstrate that this decision is incorrect."
JLR said it would not comment further while proceedings continue. "We protect our intellectual property and take legal action when necessary," the company said in a statement. "Legal proceedings are ongoing, and we won't be commenting further at this time." JLR now has six months to begin full proceedings, and is planning to take its claim against BYD to the UK courts before deliveries of the car begin in January.