Florida man guilty of murdering British teacher

A jury in Ocala, Florida, has convicted Dwain Chadwick Hall of kidnapping and murdering Sonia Exelby, a 32-year-old British music teacher he groomed online for two years before luring her to the United States, where her body was later found in a shallow grave.
Hall, 54, was found guilty on Friday 20 November of premeditated first-degree murder and kidnapping. Within minutes of the verdict, Circuit Judge Timothy McCourt sentenced him to two consecutive life terms in prison. The 12-member jury, made up of eight women and four men, had deliberated for about an hour after a four-day trial at the Marion County courthouse.
Prosecutors told the court that Hall, a roadside mechanic, met Exelby on Motherless.com, an extreme fetish website, where he used the username "AlphaSadist". Over about two years he cultivated a relationship with the vulnerable Portsmouth woman, exploiting her mental health problems, and eventually persuaded her to travel to Florida, telling her he would kill her for a payment of 3,000 pounds.
A trip presented as a sisters' weekend
Exelby flew to the United States on 10 October 2025. She told her family she was going away for a sisters' weekend, but instead Hall collected her from Gainesville Regional Airport and took her to an Airbnb in Reddick, Florida. When she repeatedly delayed meeting her sisters as planned, her loved ones reported her missing on 12 October.
Her body was found on 17 October 2025 in a shallow grave in Marion Oaks, in the 3200 block of Southwest 27th Circle, with four stab wounds to her torso and bruising. Investigators traced Hall after he used Exelby's Tesco debit card to charge 1,200 dollars to his mechanic business. He was booked into jail on suspicion of murder on 18 October 2025 and formally charged the following month.
The trial, which began on 17 November, heard graphic evidence over four days. Prosecutors called 30 witnesses and submitted 93 pieces of evidence, including a deleted video recovered from Hall's phone in which he repeatedly instructed Exelby to say that she wanted to be beaten and made to suffer. The court also heard GPS and CCTV evidence tracking the pair's movements, credit card records and DNA evidence linking the victim to a knife Hall had mailed.
Defence said she travelled willingly
Hall denied killing Exelby. His defence argued that she had travelled to Florida willingly and that he was only fulfilling her sexual desires, suggesting she had stabbed herself. Prosecutors rejected that account, telling jurors that Hall had targeted Exelby precisely because of her mental illness and had stabbed her to death for his own sadistic pleasure.
After the verdict was read, four members of Exelby's family addressed the court while facing Hall. Their collective message was one of thanks to family, friends, law enforcement, prosecutors, the judge and the state of Florida for welcoming them and giving them justice. The judge told the jury there was nothing he could say that had not already been said before imposing the life sentences.
State Attorney Bill Gladson, whose office prosecuted the case, said in a statement that families across the country confront the harsh realities of evil every day. The investigation had involved local, state, federal and international law enforcement, including Interpol, which was contacted after Exelby was reported missing, and the Florida Department of Law Enforcement.
The case has drawn attention in Britain and the United States to the dangers of online grooming, and to how predators can exploit people with mental health difficulties in closed online communities. Exelby, a piano tutor from Portsmouth, had told friends she was frightened before she travelled. Her family has described her as a much-loved daughter and sister whose death has left them devastated.
Sources: Office of the State Attorney, Fifth Judicial Circuit of Florida; Ocala Star-Banner; The Times.