How Is the UN Secretary-General Chosen?

The race to choose the next Secretary-General of the United Nations is deadlocked, with less than six weeks to go before António Guterres steps down on 31 December 2026. In the ninth informal straw poll, held on Friday, 20 November, frontrunner Rebeca Grynspan of Costa Rica kept her lead with 10 votes in favour, four against and one abstention — but two of the votes against her came from permanent members of the Security Council, enough to block her in a formal vote. Every one of the eight candidates drew opposition from at least two of the five veto-wielding powers. So how does this secretive process actually work, and what happens if the Council cannot agree in time?
The short answer is that the 15-member Security Council chooses, and the 193-member General Assembly formally appoints. Article 97 of the UN Charter states: "The Secretary-General shall be appointed by the General Assembly upon the recommendation of the Security Council." In practice, the Council does the real decision-making, and the Assembly has never rejected a candidate the Council has recommended.
The Security Council decides, the Assembly appoints
The Security Council has 15 members: five permanent members — China, France, Russia, the United Kingdom and the United States, known as the P5 — and 10 elected non-permanent members. The current elected members are Bahrain, Colombia, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Denmark, Greece, Latvia, Liberia, Pakistan, Panama and Somalia. To be recommended, a candidate needs at least nine votes in favour and must avoid a veto from any of the five permanent members. The Council's recommendation is discussed and decided at a private meeting, and the General Assembly then formally approves the nominee. The Assembly has never voted down a Council recommendation — with one historic exception, in 1950, when it extended the term of the then Secretary-General, Trygve Lie, without a Council recommendation after the Council deadlocked.
There is no fixed timetable in the Charter. General Assembly resolution 51/241 states that the Secretary-General should be appointed as early as possible, preferably no later than one month before the incumbent's term expires. In recent decades the Council has usually settled on a candidate in November or December, with the new Secretary-General starting in January.
Straw polls: the secret ballots that narrow the field
Before any formal recommendation, the Council holds a series of informal, secret straw polls. In each round, every Council member marks a paper ballot for each candidate as "encourage", "discourage" or "no opinion". The United Nations does not publish the tallies, although the numbers are often leaked to the press. The polls are a way of testing support and, crucially, of revealing whether a candidate faces a veto, without any member having to cast a formal veto in public.
In later rounds the Council switches to colour-coded paper ballots, which distinguish the votes of the five permanent members from those of the 10 elected members. That matters because a "discourage" from an elected member is a setback, while a "discourage" from a permanent member is a likely veto. The first colour-coded poll of this race was held on 16 October 2026, and the 20 November poll was the second in which the permanent members' voting pattern was revealed. Nine straw polls have now been held in this race, and none has produced a candidate free of permanent-member opposition.
Where the 2026 race stands
Eight candidates are competing to succeed Guterres, who finishes his second term at the end of December. Grynspan, a former vice-president of Costa Rica and the frontrunner in the contest, received 10 "encourage" votes, four "discourage" votes and one "no opinion" in the 20 November poll. That was a step back from her 12 "encourage" votes in an earlier November round, and two of her four "discourage" votes came from permanent members — meaning that if those members repeat their stance in a formal vote, her candidacy cannot be approved.
Rafael Grossi of Argentina, the head of the International Atomic Energy Agency, polled eight votes in favour, six against and one abstention, with three permanent members opposed. Lana Nusseibeh of the United Arab Emirates, a late entrant to the race, held at seven in favour, six against and two abstentions, with three permanent members opposed. Carolyn Rodrigues-Birkett of Guyana drew six in favour, six against and three abstentions. Turkey's Feridun Sinirlioglu received five votes in favour and 10 against, including four from permanent members, while Olara Otunnu won three votes and faced 12 against, with every permanent member opposed.
The result leaves the succession uncertain. Diplomats have raised the prospect of the United Nations being left leaderless on 1 January 2027 if no candidate can clear the Council, although the process has deadlocked before and eventually produced a consensus choice.
Who can stand, and what must candidates do?
Member states nominate the candidates, who do not need to be nationals of the country that nominates them. The 2026 process was formally opened by a joint letter from the presidents of the Security Council and the General Assembly, published on 25 November 2025, under General Assembly resolution 79/327, adopted on 5 September 2025. Each candidate files a vision statement and discloses campaign funding, and the president of the General Assembly holds public interactive dialogues with the candidates, which are webcast. The reforms were designed to make a process that was traditionally closed and secretive more open, after campaigning by civil society groups and member states, although the decisive bargaining still happens behind closed doors in the Council.
There is also an unwritten convention of regional rotation, under which the post moves between world regions. Guterres is from Portugal, in the Western European and Others group. Grynspan would be the first Secretary-General from Latin America and the Caribbean since the 1990s, and no woman has ever held the post — a fact that has made the gender of the next Secretary-General a live part of the debate.
How long does the Secretary-General serve?
The Secretary-General serves a five-year term, which can be renewed once. Guterres is serving his second term, having first taken office on 1 January 2017. His successor will take office on 1 January 2027. The Charter sets no limit on the number of terms, but the two-term pattern has held for every Secretary-General since the 1980s, and the 2026 race is a contest to choose a new office-holder rather than to renew an incumbent.
What happens if the Council cannot agree?
The Charter provides no automatic fallback if the Council deadlocks. The process simply continues — more straw polls, more negotiation among the permanent members — until a candidate acceptable to all five emerges. History shows how long that can take. In 1981, the contest between Kurt Waldheim of Austria, seeking an unprecedented third term, and Salim Salim of Tanzania, backed by African states, produced 16 inconclusive ballots before both men stepped aside and a compromise candidate, Javier Pérez de Cuéllar of Peru, was agreed.
The only time the General Assembly has acted without a Council recommendation was in 1950, when it extended Trygve Lie's term by majority vote after a succession of inconclusive Council votes. That precedent is sometimes cited in discussions of what could happen if the current deadlock persists past 31 December, but it is not a mechanism the Assembly can be assumed to use, and diplomats quoted in reporting on the 20 November poll spoke instead of the risk that the organisation could be left without a leader at the turn of the year.
Why the choice matters now
The next Secretary-General will take charge of an organisation under severe strain, with wars, funding pressures and deep divisions among the great powers that must agree on the appointment. The deadlock in the ninth straw poll shows how hard that agreement is to reach: the frontrunner leads the field, but two veto-wielding members are not yet prepared to accept her. Until one candidate can win nine votes with no permanent member opposed, the straw polls will continue — and the clock will keep running towards 31 December.