ICJ Myanmar Ruling Bolsters South Africa Gaza Case

The International Court of Justice's landmark ruling that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya could strengthen South Africa's genocide case against Israel over the war in Gaza, legal experts have said, after Pretoria welcomed the judgment as a precedent of great significance.
The World Court ruled on Thursday 19 November, by nine votes to six, that Myanmar's military campaign against the Rohingya in 2017 amounted to state-sponsored genocide, the first time in the court's 80-year history it has held a state responsible for committing genocide. The judges found around 10,000 killings, including of children, the razing of homes, widespread sexual violence and the forced exodus of more than 700,000 people.
Myanmar had argued that its clearance operations were a legitimate counterterrorism campaign. The court rejected that defence, finding that the military did not distinguish between militants and civilians, and concluding that the only reasonable inference from its actions was an intention to destroy a substantial part of the Rohingya population in northern Rakhine State.
Why Pretoria welcomed the ruling
South Africa, which filed its own case against Israel at the ICJ in December 2023, welcomed the judgment. Foreign Minister Ronald Lamola said it set an important precedent by establishing for the first time that a state had committed genocide, and called it of great significance to the case against Israel, which is not expected to be argued until 2029.
Lamola said South Africa would study the judgment carefully with a view to demonstrating, as the court had in the Rohingya case, that a state's actions, including ethnic cleansing, the killing of children, sexual violence and destruction of civilian infrastructure, can fall within the definition of genocide.
The Gambia brought the Myanmar case in November 2019 under the 1948 Genocide Convention, joined by 11 other nations. The court found that Myanmar violated the convention on multiple grounds and failed in its obligation to prevent genocide. It ordered Myanmar to facilitate the return of Rohingya refugees and pay reparations, with the terms to be decided later, and to report within two years on the restitution measures it has adopted.
A wider test for proving intent
The ruling matters for Pretoria because of how the court handled the hardest question in genocide law: intent. The court maintained that genocidal intent must be the only reasonable inference, but expanded the contextual factors it can weigh beyond a pattern of conduct to include the scale and systematic nature of the acts and the history of persecution.
Israeli legal scholar Yuval Shany said the approach gives South Africa more avenues to argue for genocide in Gaza.
Marieke de Hoon, professor of international criminal law at the University of Amsterdam, said another aspect that could resonate was the court's emphasis on the systematic nature and scale of the crimes. South Africa alleges that Israel's military operations created conditions intended to prevent births and disproportionately affected women and children in Gaza; its filing said an estimated 70 per cent of those killed were non-combatants. Israel rejects the allegations and says its operations have been conducted in accordance with international law.
Arguments that a military intent or military objective would erase the idea that there could be a genocide intent are now rejected by the court, de Hoon said. The judges found that some acts, including attacks on children and women and sexual violence, could not be explained by military objectives alone.
Not everyone agrees
The Hague Initiative for International Cooperation, a think tank funded by pro-Israeli groups, warned that the judgment would fundamentally alter how courts assess genocide allegations by imposing a lower threshold for proving intent, calling the ruling not only a verdict in a particular case but a template.
Richard Horsey, senior Asia adviser at the International Crisis Group, cautioned that proving genocide remains difficult. The ICJ has never before found that a state committed genocide, he said. The legal bar is extremely high, but what this case shows is that it is surmountable.
Myanmar's military-backed government dismissed the verdict as unfair. The court's rulings are final and binding, but it has no power to enforce them; its orders go to the United Nations Security Council. For South Africa, the judgment does not decide its case, but it has changed the legal ground on which that case will be argued.