The Daily Byte
Breaking
Welcome to The Daily Byte — real stories from across Pakistan.
Saturday, 21 November 2026 · Pakistan

The Daily Byte

Stories from Pakistan that deserve to be heard
Minor World

India Dismisses USCIRF as Biased Over Voter Claims

By The Daily Byte ·21 Nov 2026 ·4 min read
India Gate in New Delhi at sunset

India has dismissed the United States Commission on International Religious Freedom as a biased body with a political agenda, after the watchdog accused New Delhi of targeting Muslim citizens through a nationwide revision of electoral rolls.

Ministry of External Affairs spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal delivered the rebuke at the ministry's regular media briefing in New Delhi on Friday, 20 November, repeating language India first used against the commission earlier this month.

"On USCIRF, I want to repeat what I have said earlier that we see it as a biased organisation with a blatantly political agenda, and I don't think an organisation which is so prejudiced needs to be taken seriously," Jaiswal said.

What prompted the exchange

The commission, known as USCIRF, said on Thursday, 19 November, that Muslim voters in India were being removed from electoral lists, labelled as foreigners and illegally deported during the country's Special Intensive Revision of voter rolls. It urged the US State Department to designate India a Country of Particular Concern, a label for governments it says commit severe violations of religious freedom.

The commission's chair, Asif Mahmood, alleged that the Indian government was increasingly targeting Muslims through the revision exercise. Commissioner Gene Mills described the alleged expulsion of Indian citizens on the basis of their Muslim faith as a shocking escalation. The claims remain contested, and the commission's statement did not independently establish its allegations.

India's Election Commission describes the revision as an exercise to verify voter records and update electoral lists across the country. The first phase took place in Bihar in 2025, a second phase covered 12 states and union territories, and a third phase covering 19 states and union territories is now under way. Opposition parties and civil society groups have warned that genuine voters could be wrongly excluded. In May, the Supreme Court upheld the legality of the exercise and clarified that the Election Commission cannot use it to determine whether an individual is an Indian citizen.

A familiar clash

This is not the first time India has clashed with the commission. On 10 November, New Delhi described USCIRF as a biased and ill-informed organisation with a blatantly political agenda, and the commission's 2026 annual report also recommended designating India a Country of Particular Concern. USCIRF is an independent US federal agency whose recommendations to the State Department are not binding.

Jaiswal also turned the criticism back on the commission, pointing to its silence on attacks on religious places in the United States and on hate crimes and racial abuse aimed at the Indian community there.

"It is particularly telling, and you must note that the USCIRF and its commissioners have consistently kept silent on attacks on religious places in the United States, as well as on hate crimes and racial abuse that are targeted at the Indian community in the United States. Prejudiced entities like the USCIRF can hardly be taken seriously," he said.

He was referring in part to an alleged plot to attack a Hindu temple in the US state of Illinois, which was foiled last month. Prosecutors alleged that Alexandros Paporakis, 19, of Palatine, a self-identified neo-Nazi, tried to shoot a man outside the Sri Venkateswara Swami Temple in Aurora on 11 October, the first day of the Navaratri festival, but his rifle jammed. As many as 105 US lawmakers urged the Federal Bureau of Investigation to investigate the alleged attempt as a possible federal hate crime.

India's ambassador to the United States, Vinay Mohan Kwatra, had already criticised the commission on 14 November, urging it to examine its own prejudices and to stop lecturing other countries. The latest exchange underlines how a domestic dispute over voter lists has become a recurring irritant in the US-India relationship, with both sides now repeating positions they have stated several times this year.