Indonesia Asks Google to Explain 19,000 YouTube Removals

Indonesia has asked Google to justify removing more than 19,000 YouTube channels supportive of the Indonesian government, saying the move risked misinterpretation.
The country’s digital ministry made the request on Friday, after meeting representatives of Google Indonesia. The channels were removed between July and September and listed in Google’s quarterly influence operations bulletin, released on 30 October, which described them as sharing content supportive of the Indonesian government and its administration.
A breakdown of the bulletin puts the total at 19,372 channels: 6,888 removed in July, 10,134 in August and 2,350 in September. Indonesia topped the bulletin’s country list, ahead of China and Russia. Google’s bulletin said the August action also included content attacking critics of the government.
What Jakarta wants to know
The ministry asked Google for its methodology, its review process, details of how accuracy is measured and its detection error rates. It also asked how the company determined the places of origin behind the content creators or sanctioned operators.
“We asked Google to provide a written explanatory note, along with examples, detailing the parameters and methods used to detect and take action against accounts that were ultimately terminated,” said ministry senior official Mediodecci Lustarini.
Google did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the criteria it used to remove the channels, the spike in third-quarter removals, or the Indonesian government’s request for clarification.
The political backdrop
The removals follow a decline in President Prabowo Subianto’s approval ratings, with dissatisfaction mounting over the state of the economy and his flagship social programmes. His rating fell to 51% in July, one of the months tracked by Google in its latest bulletin, down from about 80% in November last year.
Google did not mention any of the Indonesian political context or elaborate on why it determined the accounts were part of coordinated influence operations. Google says it removes accounts identified as participating in coordinated influence operations under its platform policies, whatever political position they promote.
The ministry said it was awaiting Google’s written explanation. Google routinely publishes the quarterly bulletin, which contains reports of account terminations linked to countries including China, India and Indonesia as part of its investigation into coordinated influence operations.
The scale of the third-quarter action dwarfs earlier quarters. Google’s second-quarter bulletin listed 437 Indonesia-linked channels sharing content supportive of the government, against 19,372 in the third quarter, a jump of more than forty times in a single quarter.
Sources
Reuters: Indonesia asks Google to clarify removal of 19,000 YouTube channels, ministry says
Technology.org: Indonesia Asks Google to Explain YouTube Removals