Young people deserve legal job guarantee, Milburn says

Young people should have a legal guarantee of a job, training or employment support, the author of a major review of youth unemployment has told the BBC. Alan Milburn, the former Labour minister whose proposals will be unveiled on Tuesday, 17 November, said those who refuse to take up the help offered could lose their benefits.
Milburn calls the proposal an “opportunity guarantee”. It would place a legal duty on the government to ensure that young people have access to a route into employment, in a similar way to the legal responsibilities councils already hold towards homeless people and children in care. He argues that earlier employment schemes have been temporary, and that a permanent legal entitlement is needed to tackle the long-running problem of young people not in education, employment or training.
“It should be a guarantee for a young person. Because at the moment the only guarantee they’ve got is a very simple thing. To get a benefit. What sort of life is that?” he said in an interview to be broadcast on Sunday on Laura Kuenssberg Sunday.
A radical shift from benefits to support
Milburn called for a radical shift in government spending away from benefits for young people and towards measures that support them into work. He said spending on benefits for young people is 25 times as much as spending on employment support, and believes the ratio should shift to two to one. That would mean significant cuts to benefit spending alongside a substantial increase in taxpayers’ money for training, education and other forms of support.
He said the government is already spending £22 billion a year supporting young people who are economically inactive, and that the money needs to be spent differently. He acknowledged openly that the change would mean some young people losing out on benefits, arguing that the system should focus on helping people into work rather than keeping them dependent on welfare.
Milburn is also expected to call for under-25s to no longer be able to claim the health element of Universal Credit or Personal Independence Payment, moving them instead to a “youth allowance”, paid at the same level as the standard rate of Universal Credit.
Almost a million young people out of work and training
The review comes as almost one million young people in the UK are not in employment, education or training — known as Neet — according to the latest data from the Office for National Statistics. The number topped one million earlier this year for the first time in more than a decade.
Milburn argues that the scale of the problem demands a lasting legal commitment rather than another short-lived scheme. The government is expected broadly to welcome the proposals, which will be published in full on Tuesday, with a statement in Parliament and draft laws early next year.
Prime Minister Andy Burnham has described Milburn’s forthcoming report as a “watershed moment”, but stopped short of committing to implement its recommendations in full. Speaking at the Welsh Labour conference on Saturday, Burnham said the report addressed the “youth detachment” that has been on the rise since the pandemic, and insisted that paying for the reforms would not mean “more money” but “spending differently”.
Reaction to the proposals
Lord Blunkett, a former Labour home secretary, told the BBC that money saved from benefits should be reassigned to supporting employment, “at least in the immediate future”, describing the task as transferring resources from “paying for failure” into making jobs available.
The TUC welcomed Milburn’s proposal of a legal guarantee as a “game changer”, describing the number of young people not in education, employment or training as a “national emergency”. It stressed, however, that funding for additional support should not come from public service budgets.
Others were more critical. Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch has previously said the government should not spend “lots of time” on employment schemes, which she said would ultimately fail. Reform UK economy spokesman Robert Jenrick said the review would be “pointless unless we get action” straight away. Green Party leader Zack Polanski said using benefit sanctions to force young people into low-paid, insecure work would not solve the structural inequalities they face, while the Liberal Democrats want a 100-hour work experience guarantee and a careers coach for every young person.
This proposed legal guarantee is separate from the government’s existing Jobs Guarantee scheme, which is rolling out across Great Britain this month and offers fully funded six-month paid jobs to some long-term unemployed young people. Milburn’s “opportunity guarantee” would go further, creating a legal right to an offer of work, an apprenticeship, training or health treatment to help a young person into employment — and the government’s response next week will show how far ministers are prepared to go.