Oregon Sues OpenAI for $2bn Over ChatGPT Child Safety

Oregon has sued OpenAI, seeking at least $2.035 billion and alleging that the company misled parents about the safety of its ChatGPT chatbot for children while knowing that its safeguards did not work.
Attorney General Dan Rayfield filed the lawsuit on 17 November in the Multnomah County Circuit Court, as part of a new Keeping Kids Safe initiative from the Oregon Department of Justice. The state alleges that OpenAI violated Oregon’s consumer protection law, was negligent, profited unfairly at Oregonians’ expense, and created a public nuisance threatening the safety of children.
“OpenAI knows that ChatGPT is harming children, and has failed to meaningfully fix their dangerous platform,” Rayfield said. “On top of that, they’ve misled the public about the safety of their products, putting profits ahead of children’s safety.” The allegations have not been tested in court, and OpenAI has not yet publicly responded to the lawsuit.
What Oregon alleges
The state says OpenAI broke Oregon’s Unlawful Trade Practices Act in three ways: by misleading the public about how safe ChatGPT is for children, by selling a product with serious safety problems it did not disclose, and by using unfair tactics to market the product to children and teenagers.
At the heart of the complaint is how the chatbot is designed. Oregon alleges that ChatGPT was engineered to be overly affirming, telling users what they want to hear in order to keep them engaged, and that this sycophantic style is particularly dangerous when children discuss sensitive topics. The state says the chatbot’s human-like manner can foster emotional dependence in already vulnerable young people.
The complaint also points to specific harms. The state says studies have shown ChatGPT exposing children to harmful messages about self-harm, eating disorders and suicide, including providing instructions and even writing suicide notes, and that conversations with the chatbot have preceded youth suicides. It says the chatbot has also been linked to acts of violence against others by children.
Age checks and teen accounts under scrutiny
Oregon alleges that OpenAI pursued young users directly, including through an experience called ChatGPT for Teens, despite recognising the risks. The state says the teen version’s supposedly stronger safeguards are easily bypassed, and that it did not alert parents when a young user asked about risky topics such as suicide, self-harm, eating disorders or mental health.
Age verification is also challenged. OpenAI allows users as young as 13 with a parent or guardian’s consent, but Oregon says the company often fails to confirm that a parent has actually signed off, and that its age verification system frequently fails. Child safety groups have raised similar concerns about the teen accounts, saying the safeguards can in some cases be worked around very easily.
OpenAI has rolled out parental controls and other child safety features, and says it is working to make its products safer for young users. None of those changes has been enough to dissuade state attorneys general from pursuing lawsuits, and the settlements Meta has recently reached over its own child safety issues are likely to have emboldened them.
What the state is asking the court to do
Oregon is asking the court to order OpenAI to stop misrepresenting the safety and age-appropriateness of ChatGPT and ChatGPT for Teens, to disclose the harms its products pose to children, and to put protections in place that actually work. It is also seeking at least $2.035 billion in damages and civil penalties, an amount to be proved at trial rather than a fine that has already been imposed.
The lawsuit is the latest in a string of legal actions by state attorneys general over ChatGPT, many of which take issue with the chatbot’s design and how OpenAI advertises it. California has also sued the company recently. Rayfield said more actions against companies harming children would follow in the coming weeks and months, and the initiative also includes a $125 million settlement with Meta, an investigation into Discord, and a major expansion of Oregon’s Internet Crimes Against Children task force.
Anyone affected by the issues raised can contact the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline by calling or texting 988, or the Crisis Text Line by texting HOME to 741741.