The Daily Byte
Breaking
Welcome to The Daily Byte — real stories from across Pakistan.
Saturday, 21 November 2026 · Pakistan

The Daily Byte

Stories from Pakistan that deserve to be heard

Pall Mall Spyware Rules Backed by 14 Countries in Paris

By The Daily Byte ·14 Nov 2026 ·3 min read
French government ministers seated around a table at a council meeting in Paris

Fourteen countries have endorsed the first international guidelines for the companies that build and sell spyware and other hacking tools, in a move aimed at curbing abuses by an industry that has largely operated without shared rules. The Industry Guidelines were launched in Paris on 11 November under the Pall Mall Process, the initiative led by the United Kingdom and France.

The endorsing countries are Austria, the Bahamas, Costa Rica, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Poland, Slovakia, Switzerland, the United Kingdom and the United States. The guidelines are voluntary and non-binding, and they do not create new legal obligations or a licensing regime. Instead, they set out what governments expect from firms across the whole supply chain, from developers and brokers to resellers, integrators and the investors who finance them.

Four pillars for a shadowy market

The framework is organised around four pillars: compliance with regulations and international norms, corporate due diligence, risk management, and monitoring. Companies are expected to vet their customers before selling, to keep checking how their tools are used afterwards, and to suspend sales, transfers and support where credible evidence shows a serious risk of irresponsible use, or where serious abuse has already taken place.

The guidelines also ask firms to build safeguards into their products, including limiting the data their tools collect, restricting onward transfers and keeping the ability to cut off access. They call for tighter controls on which employees can reach sensitive surveillance technology, and for due diligence on suppliers that includes checking their security practices. Notably, the definition of the industry explicitly covers investors and financiers, including venture capital and private equity funds, family offices and offshore structures.

The rules cover commercial cyber intrusion capabilities, a category that includes spyware able to break into phones, read messages and track locations. Activities carried out purely for defence, academic research, digital forensics or security testing, including penetration testing and bug bounties, fall outside the intended scope.

Human rights groups want stronger controls

Human rights organisations welcomed the agreement but said it does not go far enough. Natalia Krapiva, senior technology and legal counsel at Access Now, was among those arguing that the final text lacks the enforcement teeth needed to hold companies to account. Civil society groups had urged the process to bar sales to non-state actors except for legitimate security research, and to require clear limits on who can buy these tools. The guidelines stop short of that, relying on voluntary commitments and national law instead.

The industry guidelines are the second stage of the Pall Mall Process, which the UK and France launched at Lancaster House in February 2024. The first stage, a Code of Practice for States agreed in April 2025, asks governments to regulate the market and buy responsibly, and now has 27 supporters. Fifteen of those states did not sign up to the new industry guidelines, a gap campaigners are likely to highlight as the process continues.

The guidelines also acknowledge that automation and large language models could change how quickly and widely intrusion tools can be built and used, although they do not attempt to regulate general AI development. For now, their test will be whether spyware firms and their backers treat voluntary standards as a floor to build on, or as a ceiling they can comfortably ignore.

Source: Undercode News | Yeandel