Premier League Clubs Vote 18-2 to Cover Man City Legal Costs

Premier League clubs have voted 18-2 to cover the legal costs of the league’s five board directors if Manchester City’s sponsors sue them, in the latest twist in the long-running financial rules case.
Representatives of all 20 clubs met in London on Thursday for the first time since an independent commission ruled in September that City had breached the league’s financial rules between 2009 and 2018. The vote extends legal indemnity to chief executive Richard Masters, chair Alison Brittain and non-executive directors Mai Fyfield, Dharmash Mistry and Matthew Ryder KC.
Only Manchester City and Nottingham Forest voted against. BBC Sport reported that Forest’s opposition was on procedural grounds rather than support for City, with the club feeling it had not been given enough information or time to consider a decision carrying potentially significant financial responsibilities.
Why the vote was needed
Under the league’s current articles of association, a director is only financially covered if they win a legal case brought by a third party. The amendment means the five directors will be protected win or lose, and the costs will be shared by all 20 clubs under collective responsibility — meaning City would, in theory, pay a twentieth of the bill for lawsuits brought by its own sponsors.
The vote followed legal threats from two of City’s sponsors. Etihad Airways said in October that it was considering legal action against the Premier League, saying the league’s communication of the commission’s findings had created damaging implications for the airline despite it not being named in the published decision. Etisalat, another City sponsor, has also said it is weighing its legal options.
The potential exposure is large. Reports have put the legal expenses at hundreds of millions of pounds if a corporate defamation case is heard, and the proposal needed a 14-6 majority to pass.
City maintain their innocence
City have always maintained their innocence and have appealed against the commission’s findings, with an outcome expected in early 2027. The verdict itself is unaffected by Thursday’s vote, and no sanction has yet been determined.
At the meeting, City chief financial officer Ingo Bank asked Brittain whether the vote had been brought as a direct result of the legal threats from Etihad and Etisalat. Brittain declined to comment, according to reports of the meeting.
The result leaves the league’s leadership financially protected as the appeal process continues, but it also underlines how the case continues to divide the clubs, with the two dissenting votes coming from the club at the centre of it and one other.
Sources: GiveMeSport | Sports Illustrated