Romania wins Rosia Montana $6.5bn arbitration

Romania has definitively won its long-running arbitration fight over the Roşia Montană gold mining project, after an international panel rejected a claim for about $6.5 billion brought by Canada’s Gabriel Resources.
An ad hoc committee of the World Bank’s International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) rejected Gabriel Resources’ application to annul a 2024 award in full, Romania’s finance ministry said. The decision, dated 13 November, upholds the award of 8 March 2024, which dismissed the company’s claims entirely.
With the annulment request refused, the award is now definitive and binding. The ministry said the decision exhausts the final extraordinary legal remedy available under the ICSID Convention, bringing a dispute that began in 2015 to a close within the ICSID system.
The largest claim ever brought against Romania
Gabriel Resources and its Jersey-based subsidiary had sought damages of about $6.5 billion — the largest financial claim ever brought against the Romanian state in an international arbitration, equivalent to roughly 1.5% of Romania’s projected gross domestic product for 2026, according to the finance ministry.
The claimants argued that Romania had breached bilateral investment treaties with Canada and the United Kingdom in its handling of the planned gold and silver mine at Roşia Montană in Alba County. The tribunal ruled in March 2024 that Romania had breached none of its obligations under the two treaties and dismissed the demands in full.
The annulment committee rejected all five grounds on which Gabriel had sought to overturn that award, the company confirmed in its own statement. The award’s order requiring Gabriel to pay about $10 million of Romania’s costs, plus interest, therefore remains in force.
A decade-long dispute over a UNESCO site
Gabriel Resources holds an 80.69% interest in Roşia Montană Gold Corporation, which has held the exploitation licence for the project since October 2000. In June 2024, the Romanian authorities refused to extend that licence, a refusal the company is challenging before the Romanian courts.
The mining landscape at Roşia Montană, inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List in 2021, remains protected as a result of the ruling, the finance ministry said.
President Nicuşor Dan welcomed the decision on 14 November, describing the mining project as deeply illegal and an attempt to cause irreparable damage to the environment and national heritage. He also announced a posthumous national honour for Marius Liviu Haroşa, a lawyer involved in the case.
Gabriel Resources said the dismissal had material implications for its financial position and ability to continue as a going concern, and that its board was reviewing its position with legal and financial advisers. The committee directed the two sides to share the fees and expenses of the committee and ICSID equally, and ordered Romania to reimburse Gabriel about $211,000 in costs it had advanced.