The Daily Byte
Breaking
Welcome to The Daily Byte — real stories from across Pakistan.
Saturday, 21 November 2026 · Pakistan

The Daily Byte

Stories from Pakistan that deserve to be heard
Minor Markets

Shore Upgrades Close Brothers to Buy After Sell-Off

By The Daily Byte ·14 Nov 2026 ·3 min read
The entrance to Close Brothers' London headquarters, with the company name on the stone facade

Shore Capital has upgraded Close Brothers to 'buy' from 'hold', arguing that the sharp sell-off in the FTSE 250 lender after a critical report by short-seller Viceroy Research was overdone. The shares were up 3.7% at 358.64p at 1050 GMT on Friday, after Shore also cut its price target to 490p from 510p.

What Viceroy alleged

Close Brothers tumbled on Monday after Viceroy said the company had "systematically misrepresented" its exposure to the car finance scandal. The short-seller, known for its exposes on Wirecard and Home Reit, argued that the Financial Conduct Authority's motor finance redress scheme would force Close Brothers to "at least, double its existing provisions".

Viceroy put the group's redress exposure at between £572 million and £1.2 billion, well above its current provision of £300 million. It warned that further provisions could breach the bank's CET1 regulatory capital restrictions and create "an equity wipeout event", with its base case indicating equity-holders would be "substantially wiped out in a restructure".

Close Brothers responded that it "strongly disagrees" with the report. The company said its provisioning approach for motor finance commissions and the resulting impact on its capital position was "in accordance with UK-adopted international accounting standards and follows a robust governance process".

Shore's case for buying

Shore Capital argued that the Viceroy report "significantly exaggerates" the redress risks, noting that management has firmly rejected its assumptions. "At today's valuation, we think the shares more than compensate for remaining regulatory uncertainty, offering significant upside if the FCA outcome aligns closer to management's view than Viceroy's severe scenarios," the broker said, according to Sharecast.

The upgrade came despite Shore describing Close Brothers' half-year results as "slightly disappointing", with the loan book contracting 2% to £9.2 billion and adjusted operating profit falling to £65.2 million from £80.5 million.

Results, losses and 600 job cuts

A day after the Viceroy note was published, Close Brothers reported a narrowing of its first-half losses and said it would cut about 600 jobs by the end of the 2027 financial year as it accelerates its cost-cutting programme. The operating loss before tax was £65.5 million, an improvement on the £102.2 million loss a year earlier, mainly reflecting an additional £135 million motor finance provision taken in October 2025.

Adjusted operating profit fell 19% to £65.2 million and adjusted operating income was 6% lower at £326.6 million. The CET1 capital ratio rose to 14.3% from 13.8%, helped by the sale of Winterflood and lower risk-weighted assets. The group now expects about £25 million of annualised savings in the 2026 financial year and around £60 million by the end of 2027.

Chief executive Mike Morgan said: "Our CET1 capital ratio remains strong at 14.3% and we are confident that this leaves us well placed to absorb a range of potential outcomes from the FCA's proposed motor finance commission redress scheme."

The shares did not recover immediately after the results, falling 7% to 332.40p on Tuesday, according to Sharecast. The eventual outcome of the FCA redress scheme remains the key uncertainty for the lender, and Shore's upgrade is a judgement that the market has priced in a worse result than the broker expects.