The Daily Byte
Breaking
Welcome to The Daily Byte — real stories from across Pakistan.
Saturday, 21 November 2026 · Pakistan

The Daily Byte

Stories from Pakistan that deserve to be heard
Minor World

Top Court Clarifies Consent in Sex Assault Cases

By The Daily Byte ·21 Nov 2026 ·5 min read
The Supreme Court of Canada building in Ottawa with the Canadian flag flying

Canada's Supreme Court has handed down two rulings clarifying how consent is proved in sexual assault trials, upholding an aggravated sexual assault conviction in one case and ordering a new trial in another.

Degale conviction upheld

In R. v. Degale, the court unanimously confirmed the conviction of an Ontario man for aggravated sexual assault. The case dated to an evening in December 2021, when a woman emerged from a van injured and bleeding and told neighbours that someone was trying to kill her. She was taken to hospital and needed surgery for multiple serious injuries. Neither the complainant nor the accused testified at trial.

The trial judge found that the Crown had proved the physical element of the offence beyond a reasonable doubt, saying it defied “common sense and human experience” that the complainant had consented to being injured in the way she was. But the judge acquitted, ruling the Crown had failed to prove criminal intent, because there was no evidence the complainant had told the accused she did not consent, or that he knew of it. The Ontario Court of Appeal disagreed, holding that the same evidence that proved the physical element also proved the accused's state of mind, and it set aside the acquittal and substituted a conviction.

Writing for the majority, Chief Justice Richard Wagner and Justice Mary Moreau said the trial judge had made “a clear legal error” by requiring the Crown to produce evidence that the complainant had communicated her non-consent. “Canadian law has recognized for decades that there is no legal requirement to communicate non-consent to sexual contact,” the justices said. The trial judge, they said, had overlooked circumstantial evidence that the accused knew of, wilfully ignored, or was reckless about the complainant's lack of consent.

Justice Sheilah Martin agreed that the conviction should stand, but for different reasons on one point. She argued that section 273.2(b) of the Criminal Code gives the Crown a second route to proving intent: showing the accused intended the touching but failed to take reasonable steps to make sure consent had been communicated. The majority disagreed that the provision created that second pathway. Martin said the provision reflects “a basic premise: a person who wishes to engage in sexual activity bears a legal responsibility to turn their mind to whether the other person is communicating voluntary agreement.”

Defence lawyer Howard Krongold told Canadian Lawyer the ruling mattered because it confirmed an accused could be unable to raise the honest-mistaken-belief defence, yet still be acquitted if the Crown failed to prove intent. Ontario's Attorney General's office said the province had “zero tolerance for any form of sexual violence” and that it respected the decisions and was carefully reviewing them.

Bilinski sent back for a new trial

In R. v. Bilinski, the court split 7-2 and ordered a new trial for an Alberta man who had been acquitted of sexual assault by a jury. The events took place in 2019, when the complainant invited her former boyfriend to her home and texted him beforehand that he would have to wear a condom if they had sex. During sex, he removed the condom. The complainant later contacted police. At trial, he did not argue that he had honestly but mistakenly believed she had consented.

The trial judge failed to explain clearly to the jury that consent must be communicated through words or conduct, and that a person cannot simply assume someone has consented. The Alberta Court of Appeal ordered a new trial, and the Supreme Court agreed. Writing for the majority, Justice Martin said the trial judge's error mattered because the jury could have acquitted on the basis that the accused believed or assumed the complainant had consented.

Martin also dealt with the appeal court's phrase that once a jury found a complainant had not consented, it should have “little difficulty” concluding the accused knew of, wilfully ignored, or was reckless about it. She said trial judges were not required to give that instruction, since it could interfere with the jury's job of independently assessing the accused's state of mind — though they could give it in the right circumstances. Justices Suzanne Côté and Malcolm Rowe dissented, saying there was no legal basis to interfere with the acquittal.

Bilinski's lawyer, Yoav Niv, welcomed the majority's findings on the jury instruction, but worried about a retrial more than seven years after the alleged offence. “At some point, the finality of a jury's acquittal must carry real weight,” he said.

Taken together, the two rulings leave the core rule unchanged — the Crown must still prove the accused's state of mind beyond a reasonable doubt — while making clear that silence, or the absence of a spoken refusal, is not by itself a defence.