Trump Orders Contractors to Alert White House on Probes

President Donald Trump has signed an executive order requiring every federal contractor to notify the White House before answering requests from Congress about its work with the executive branch.
The order, Executive Order 14438, was signed on Friday, 20 November. It directs contractors to tell the White House and their contracting agencies about any pending or future congressional request concerning their communications or work with the executive branch, and to follow instructions to withhold material the White House or the agency has determined is protected by executive privilege.
The requirements also apply to subcontractors working on federal contracts, and agencies must take steps to make contractors responsible for ensuring their subcontractors comply. The Office of Management and Budget is to issue guidance on how agencies should enforce the rules and coordinate responses.
Penalties for non-compliance
Contractors that fail to comply could face serious consequences. The order says contracting agencies shall consider all appropriate enforcement action, consistent with the law, including the possible termination or cancellation of contracts and the possible debarment or suspension of contractors.
Each agency must promptly inform all of its contractors and subcontractors of the new obligations and require them to comply. The order states that it is to be implemented consistently with applicable law and subject to the availability of appropriations, and that it creates no right enforceable against the United States.
Why the White House says it is needed
The order argues that the executive branch must be able to work closely with its employees and contractors on sensitive matters without fear that confidential information will be released to unauthorised third parties. It says the doctrine of executive privilege, which the Supreme Court has recognised as rooted in the separation of powers, protects confidential executive branch information from disclosure.
It also argues that Congress cannot seek information from the executive branch without a valid legislative purpose that does not intrude on core executive functions, and it accuses some congressional leaders of threatening to intrude on executive prerogatives by seeking confidential information and harassing private companies that contract with the federal government.
The White House said uncoordinated disclosures could expose privileged information, duplicate litigation and disrupt sensitive government programmes, including work on national and homeland security. It said contractors responding independently to congressional requests could force the administration into costly legal disputes.
Ahead of Democratic control of Congress
The order comes as the Trump administration prepares to face investigations from Democrats, who will take control of both chambers of Congress in January after big wins in this month's midterm elections. It follows a directive issued this week by White House Counsel Will Scharf requiring federal agencies to obtain White House approval before employees agree to testify before Congress.
Legal experts expect the restrictions to face challenges, particularly if contractors are told to withhold information sought through congressional subpoenas. Executive privilege allows presidents to protect certain confidential communications, but courts can intervene in disputes over Congress's authority to obtain information.
The order sets up a potentially significant battle over presidential power and lawmakers' authority to scrutinise the White House, with the first test likely to come when the new Congress begins its investigations in January.