UK tribunal: secret Apple encryption order must be admitted

The British government can no longer pretend it never ordered Apple to keep a way into its customers' encrypted data. The Investigatory Powers Tribunal ruled on Thursday that the Home Office must acknowledge it served Apple with a secret technical capability notice, rejecting the government's argument that admitting the order exists would damage national security.
The government had insisted it could neither confirm nor deny the order, the standard position on security matters. But the tribunal found that so much information was already in the public domain that confirming the order would do little, if any, damage. The three judges pointed to extensive press reporting, statements by US officials, and media briefings they concluded had been authorised by the UK government itself.
Two notices, one dispute
The story began in January 2025, when Britain issued an initial notice widely reported as demanding access to end-to-end encrypted iCloud backups belonging to users anywhere in the world. Apple responded in February 2025 by withdrawing Advanced Data Protection, its opt-in feature that extends end-to-end encryption to iCloud backups, photos and notes, for new users in the UK. Without it, that data remains encrypted but Apple holds the keys and can disclose content in response to a valid legal demand.
That first demand was dropped after months of negotiations with the administration of US President Donald Trump. In August 2025, the then US director of national intelligence, Tulsi Gabbard, announced that the UK had agreed to drop its demand for access to Americans' encrypted data. But in July 2026 Britain issued a second notice, reported to apply only to Apple's UK customers, and Apple launched a fresh legal challenge.
A technical capability notice, issued under the Investigatory Powers Act 2016, can require a company to put systems in place so it can comply with a future warrant, including retaining the ability to remove encryption it applies to customers' data where that is reasonably practicable.
What the ruling does and does not decide
Thursday's ruling decides only that the existence of the notice can be acknowledged. It does not decide whether the order is lawful, and it does not disclose what the order actually requires. The tribunal said the extent to which details of the notice could be disclosed without damaging national security or the public interest would be dealt with at later hearings. A substantive hearing is expected in the first half of 2027.
Civil rights groups welcomed the decision. Akiko Hart, director of Liberty, called the ruling a victory for transparency, saying the public deserve to know when the government's actions undermine their privacy and safety. Privacy International and Liberty are also challenging the technical capability notice regime itself, alongside Apple and two individuals.
The government defended the order. A spokesperson said the right to privacy was crucial but should not come at the expense of public safety, adding that the notice simply requires Apple to maintain the ability to help police and intelligence agencies pursue criminals. The spokesperson added that decisions affecting the safety of the British public must be made by democratically elected governments and independent judges, not in the boardrooms of technology companies.
Apple did not immediately comment on the ruling. The case will now move towards open hearings on how far ministers can go in demanding access to encrypted data, a question with implications for every technology company operating in the UK.
Sources: Reuters; The Register.