What Is a Grand Jury and How Does It Work?

A grand jury is a group of ordinary citizens asked to decide whether there is enough evidence for someone to be charged with a serious crime. It does not decide whether the person is guilty. It decides whether a trial should happen at all. The phrase has been in the headlines again because a federal judge in Florida has cleared the way for the release of grand jury transcripts from the investigation into Jeffrey Epstein, a ruling that turned a rarely discussed part of the American legal system into a topic of everyday conversation. To understand what that ruling means, it helps to know what a grand jury is, what it does, and why its work is normally kept secret.
The idea is old. The United States Courts handbook for grand jurors traces it to the Magna Carta, the English constitutional document granted by King John in 1215, and to the first English grand juries, made up of twelve men summoned to inquire into crimes in their local community. Over time the institution changed. Grand jury proceedings became secret, and the grand jury became independent of the Crown, able to vote for an indictment or refuse one as it thought proper, without regard to the recommendations of a judge, a prosecutor or anyone else. The founders of the United States thought the institution important enough to include it in the Bill of Rights. The Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution says that no person shall be held to answer for a capital or otherwise infamous crime unless on a presentment or indictment of a grand jury.
What a grand jury is
A grand jury is a panel of citizens empowered by law to investigate possible criminal conduct and to decide whether criminal charges should be brought. It has two functions, which lawyers describe as investigatory and accusatory. In its investigatory role it can obtain and review documents and other evidence, hear sworn testimony from witnesses, and issue subpoenas compelling people to appear or to produce evidence. In its accusatory role it decides whether there is probable cause to believe that one or more people committed a particular offence. Probable cause is a lower standard than the proof beyond reasonable doubt required to convict someone at trial. The grand jury is asking whether the evidence is strong enough to justify putting a person on trial, not whether that person is guilty.
A federal grand jury in the United States has between 16 and 23 members, and at least 12 of them must agree before an indictment can be returned. The members are drawn from the community in the district where the grand jury sits, and the same panel typically serves for a fixed term, considering many cases rather than just one. That is one of the main differences from the jury most people picture when they think of a courtroom. A trial jury, known as a petit jury, is chosen for a single case, hears evidence from both sides, and returns a verdict of guilty or not guilty. A grand jury serves over a longer period, hears a series of cases, and makes a narrower decision: should this person be charged?
The grand jury is an arm of the court that summons it, and its subject matter and geographical jurisdiction are those of that court. Matters can be brought to its attention in three ways: by the United States Attorney or an assistant, by the court that impanelled it, or from the personal knowledge of one of its own members. The Congressional Research Service, in its summary of federal grand jury law, notes that a federal grand jury may begin an examination even without probable cause or any other level of suspicion that a crime has been committed. Its inquiries may be triggered by tips, rumours, evidence offered by the prosecutor, or the personal knowledge of the grand jurors themselves.
Grand jury versus trial jury
The difference between the two kinds of jury is the easiest way to understand the grand jury, and it is also the source of most confusion about it. A trial jury listens to evidence offered by the prosecution and by the defence, if the defence chooses to offer any, and then decides guilt or innocence. A grand jury normally hears only the evidence presented by the government, which tends to show that a crime was committed. It usually does not hear evidence for the defence. The person under investigation is not present, does not have a lawyer in the room, and does not get to cross-examine witnesses. Grand jurors are entitled to question witnesses themselves, to request additional evidence or subpoenas, and to decline to indict even when prosecutors recommend that they do so.
That one-sided process is deliberate, but it is also why the grand jury has critics. The United States Supreme Court has described the grand jury's historic office as a shield against arbitrary or oppressive action, ensuring that serious criminal accusations are brought only on the considered judgment of a representative body of citizens. A federal district court put the same point more bluntly in 2025, saying the purpose of a grand jury is to serve as a shield against unjust prosecutions, not as a sword to rubber-stamp criminal charges. At the same time, because prosecutors control what the grand jury hears, the process depends heavily on the grand jurors taking their independent role seriously. The handbook for grand jurors stresses that a grand jury can refuse an indictment regardless of what a judge or prosecutor recommends.
What happens in the grand jury room
Grand jury proceedings are held in secret, and no judge presides over the sessions. The prosecutor presents the case, calls witnesses, and shows the grand jury documents and other evidence. Witnesses give evidence under oath. The grand jury can compel a witness to testify, and a witness generally cannot bring a lawyer into the grand jury room, although the witness may be able to consult a lawyer outside it. The grand jurors deliberate in private and vote in private. If at least 12 members agree that probable cause exists, the grand jury returns an indictment, sometimes called a true bill. If it does not agree, it returns no bill, and no charge is brought on that evidence.
An indictment is a formal written accusation. It must be a plain, concise and definite written statement of the essential facts constituting the offence charged, and it must give the citation of the statute, rule or regulation the defendant is alleged to have violated. The United States Attorney must also sign the indictment before a person can be prosecuted on it. The handbook describes this as a system of checks: the government and the grand jury act as checks upon each other. A person who is indicted is not convicted. The indictment simply means the case will go to trial, where the prosecution must prove the charges beyond reasonable doubt and the defendant has the full rights of a trial, including a lawyer and the chance to challenge the evidence.
The right to a grand jury indictment applies to serious federal crimes, and it can be waived, including as part of a plea agreement. A valid waiver must be made in open court and after the defendant has been advised of the nature of the charge and of the defendant's rights. The position is different in many states. The constitutional requirement applies to federal cases, and in most states a prosecution can begin either with an indictment or with an information or complaint filed by the prosecutor. Some states use grand juries extensively, others rarely, and the rules about their size and powers vary from state to state.
Why grand jury proceedings are secret
Secrecy is the most distinctive feature of the grand jury, and it is governed by Rule 6 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure. Rule 6(e) says that a grand juror, an interpreter, a stenographer, a recording operator, a typist who transcribes recorded testimony, an attorney for the government, or anyone to whom disclosure is made under the rule must not disclose matters occurring before the grand jury, except as the rules provide. A knowing violation can be punished as contempt of court. Proceedings other than deliberations and voting are recorded, and the recording or transcript remains in the custody of the government attorney unless a court orders otherwise.
The secrecy rule exists for several reasons, identified by the Supreme Court in the case of Douglas Oil Co. v. Petrol Stops Northwest. Publicity could discourage witnesses from coming forward or make them less willing to speak candidly. It could expose witnesses to retaliation or inducements, alert people under investigation who might flee or interfere with the inquiry, and publicly stigmatise people who were investigated but never charged. The rule protects a matter occurring before the grand jury, which can cover testimony and transcripts, but also subpoenas, documents prepared specifically for the grand jury, and records whose disclosure would reveal what the grand jury was investigating or what evidence it sought.
There are important limits to the secrecy. Witnesses themselves are generally not bound by Rule 6(e), so a person who testified can usually talk about their own testimony, although they cannot reveal what other people said or how the grand jury voted. A fact does not automatically become secret merely because it was also told to a grand jury; if the same fact is known from an independent source, it can be reported. And the secrecy has no general expiry date. Federal grand jury records do not automatically become public when an investigation ends, when charges are filed, when a defendant is convicted, or even when decades have passed. The Supreme Court has held that although the reasons for secrecy become weaker after a grand jury finishes its work, they do not disappear simply because the investigation is over.
When grand jury transcripts can be released
Because secrecy is the default, releasing grand jury material normally requires a court order under one of the exceptions in Rule 6(e). Those exceptions allow disclosure to government lawyers and personnel who need it to enforce federal criminal law, and allow a court to authorise disclosure in connection with a judicial proceeding, among other limited circumstances. A court that orders disclosure can set the manner, time and conditions under which it happens. A few federal appeals courts have also recognised a limited judicial power to release exceptionally old records for historical reasons, but that is not a general rule.
That framework is why the Epstein transcripts have been in the news. A judge had previously declined to release the grand jury records from the Florida investigation, citing the usual secrecy rules. The Justice Department then asked the court to unseal them so they could be released with other records required to be disclosed under the Epstein Files Transparency Act, a law signed in November 2026 that requires the release of unclassified records relating to the Epstein and Maxwell investigations. Judge Rodney Smith ruled that the new law overrode the usual secrecy rules for the transcripts from the 2006 to 2007 Florida investigation, the earliest known federal inquiry into Epstein. The Justice Department must now review the material and decide what can be made public, with the Act setting a deadline of 19 December for the wider release of Epstein-related files. Requests to unseal the grand jury records from the later New York cases against Epstein and Maxwell remain pending before a different judge.
The episode shows how the system works in practice. Secrecy is strong, but it is a rule made by law, and a later law can change it. A court still has to be asked, and the judge still decides what may be released and on what terms. Material that would identify victims or describe the abuse of children is expected to be withheld, and the timing of any release depends on the review process. The transcripts, if released, would show what prosecutors presented to the grand jury in Florida and shed light on why that early federal case ended without charges being filed.
What an indictment does and does not mean
The most common misunderstanding about grand juries is to treat an indictment as a finding of guilt. It is not. It is a finding that there is probable cause to believe a crime was committed and that a particular person committed it. The person indicted is presumed innocent, and the prosecution must still prove its case at trial. Many people who are indicted are acquitted, and some cases end in plea agreements before trial. Equally, a decision not to indict does not prove that nothing happened. It means only that this grand jury, on the evidence it heard, did not find probable cause, or chose not to charge. Prosecutors can sometimes present a case again, and other investigations can continue.
The grand jury survives today chiefly as an American institution, and it remains controversial. Supporters say it is a vital check on prosecutorial power, a body of citizens standing between the state and the individual. Critics say that because prosecutors control the evidence, grand juries almost always do what prosecutors ask, and that secrecy makes the process hard to scrutinise. Both arguments were in the background when the Epstein transcripts were debated. The grand jury heard the evidence in secret nearly two decades ago, and the public argument now is about whether the public should be allowed to see what it heard. Whatever the outcome in that case, the rules that kept the transcripts sealed for so long are the same rules that govern every federal grand jury: citizens, chosen from the community, hearing evidence in secret, and deciding whether a charge should be brought.