What Is Transnational Repression? Gupta Case Explained

On 20 November 2026, a court in New York sentenced an Indian man to more than 19 years in prison for plotting to kill a Sikh separatist activist on American soil. Prosecutors said the plot was directed by an employee of the government of India. The case is one of the clearest examples yet of what governments, police forces and human rights groups call transnational repression: a state reaching across its own borders to silence, intimidate or harm its critics abroad.
This explainer sets out what transnational repression means, how it works, why the Nikhil Gupta case matters, and what is being done about it.
What is transnational repression?
Transnational repression is when a foreign government attempts to threaten, silence, coerce or even harm members of dissident communities, vocal diaspora groups, or religious or ethnic minority communities outside its own territory. That is the definition used by the FBI, which investigates it in the United States. The aim, in the FBI's words, is either to silence the targets or to get them to express opinions in the way that the foreign government wants.
The Congressional Research Service, which briefs members of the US Congress, describes it in similar terms: a range of tactics that foreign governments use to reach beyond their borders to harm, intimidate, threaten, harass or coerce individuals, with victims often including political dissidents and activists, journalists, political opponents, religious and ethnic minority groups, and members of diaspora and exile communities. The human rights organisation Freedom House, which has tracked the practice since 2021, defines it as governments reaching across borders to silence dissent among diasporas and exiles, including through assassinations, illegal deportations, abductions, digital threats, abuse of Interpol, and intimidation of family members.
The United Nations human rights office puts it this way: transnational repression denotes acts conducted or directed by a state, or its proxy, to deter, silence or punish dissent, criticism or human rights advocacy towards it, expressed from outside its territory. There is no single agreed statutory definition in US federal law, a gap that US lawmakers and campaigners have repeatedly noted, but the concept is now well established in law enforcement, diplomacy and human rights work.
What makes transnational repression distinct is the cross-border element. Ordinary repression happens inside a country's own territory. Transnational repression follows people who have left: exiles, refugees, naturalised citizens, and even US-born citizens whose families come from the country in question. It treats criticism voiced abroad as a threat to be dealt with abroad, and it violates the sovereignty of the country where the target lives.
The Gupta case: what happened
The case that brought the term back into the headlines concerns Nikhil Gupta, a 55-year-old Indian national, and Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, a US citizen of Indian origin, a lawyer in New York, and a vocal advocate for a sovereign Sikh state in northern India. Pannun leads Sikhs for Justice, a US-based organisation that campaigns for the secession of Punjab as an independent Sikh state, Khalistan.
According to the US Department of Justice, in or about May 2023, Gupta was recruited by his co-defendant, Vikash Yadav, an employee of the government of India, to orchestrate the assassination of Pannun in the United States. At Yadav's direction, Gupta contacted a person he believed to be a criminal associate, but who was in fact a confidential source working with the Drug Enforcement Administration, for help in contracting a hitman to murder Pannun in New York City. Gupta and Yadav arranged for 15,000 dollars in cash to be delivered to a purported hitman who was actually an undercover US law enforcement officer, court papers show. The plot was foiled before anyone was harmed.
Gupta pleaded guilty in February 2026 to a superseding indictment charging him with murder-for-hire, conspiracy to commit murder-for-hire, and conspiracy to commit money laundering. On Friday 20 November 2026, US District Judge Victor Marrero sentenced him to 235 months in prison, 19 years and seven months, at a hearing in Manhattan federal court. Federal prosecutors had recommended a sentence of about 24 years; Gupta's defence had asked for 12 years followed by three years of supervised release. The 235-month term sits at the lower end of the US Sentencing Guidelines range of 235 to 293 months.
Addressing the court on Friday, Gupta said he regretted straying from the nonviolent example set by Indian independence leader Mahatma Gandhi. Pannun, who was present in court, said he was grateful to the US for prosecuting Gupta and that he would keep advocating for Sikh sovereignty. The US Attorney for the Southern District of New York, Jamie McDonald, said: "Today's prison sentence reflects the seriousness of Nikhil Gupta's conduct and should serve as a clear warning: the Department of Justice and its law enforcement partners will pursue and hold accountable anyone who attempts to commit violence on US soil or against US citizens."
The case sits alongside a related one in Canada. In June 2023, the Sikh activist Hardeep Singh Nijjar was shot dead in British Columbia, days before a state visit to the US by Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Canada has alleged that Indian government agents were involved in that killing, an allegation India has denied. US prosecutors have described the Gupta plot as part of a broader effort by the Indian government to target dissidents abroad, a characterisation India has rejected. The Gupta case is the first of these alleged plots to end in a US conviction and a long prison sentence.
What forms does it take?
Assassination plots are the most extreme form, but transnational repression usually works through quieter pressure. The FBI lists the main forms it investigates: stalking, online disinformation campaigns, harassment, intimidation or threats, forcing or coercing the victim to return to their country of origin, threatening or detaining family members or friends in the country of origin, and abusive legal practices such as lawsuits, asset freezes, or withholding legal documents like passports.
Freedom House divides the practice into broad categories. The first is direct attacks by the state of origin against individuals abroad, including assassination, assault, physical intimidation, abduction and unexplained disappearance. The second is the co-optation of actors or institutions in other countries to subject a target to detention, rendition or unlawful deportation, including through alleged abuse of Interpol systems, such as politically motivated red notices. The third covers indirect tactics: spyware and surveillance, threats sent over social media or by phone, and threats and violence against family members back home, known as coercion by proxy.
Digital tactics have grown fast. Targets report coordinated online harassment, hacking of their accounts, and surveillance through spyware installed on their phones. In April 2023, the US Department of Justice indicted Chinese operatives over a transnational repression campaign run through a Chinese police overseas service station in Manhattan. In July 2023, the US State Department classified the Hong Kong Police Force's bounties on eight prominent dissidents living abroad as an instance of transnational repression. The pattern is the same in each case: the target's criticism is public and lawful where they live, and the response is covert, coercive and cross-border.
How widespread is it?
Freedom House has documented a sharp rise. Its database recorded 854 direct, physical incidents of transnational repression, covering assassination, kidnapping, assault, detention or deportation, between 2014 and 2022, committed by 38 governments in 91 countries. By 2025, some 54 countries had been documented as committing transnational repression, according to Freedom House. The figures cover only incidents that could be verified, and researchers say the true number is likely higher, because many victims do not report what happens to them.
China is identified by Freedom House as responsible for the largest share of cases since 2014, followed by Turkey, Russia, Tajikistan, Egypt, Turkmenistan, Cambodia, Iran, Uzbekistan and Belarus. But the Gupta case shows the practice is not limited to one region or one political system. The targets are also diverse: journalists in exile, human rights activists, religious minorities, ethnic minorities, former officials, and the families of all of them. What they have in common is that they criticise a government from outside its borders, and that government would rather they stopped.
The effect on the victims goes beyond the individual incident. People who have fled persecution find that the persecution has followed them. Some stop speaking publicly. Some avoid community events. Some move home, change their routines, or cut contact with family. That chilling effect is part of the point: transnational repression does not need to reach every critic if it frightens enough of them into silence.
How are governments responding?
In the United States, the FBI has a dedicated stream of work on transnational repression, including a public web page, unclassified counterintelligence bulletins for targeted communities, and a threat intimidation guide translated into more than 60 languages. Transnational repression can be reported through the FBI's general hotline, at tips.fbi.gov or on 1-800-CALL-FBI. The Bureau investigates because the conduct usually violates US federal law, and because it infringes constitutional rights that extend not only to US citizens and permanent residents but to anyone on US soil.
Prosecutions are the sharpest tool, and the Gupta sentence is the most significant so far in a case linked to India. The Justice Department has also brought cases against operatives working for China, Iran and Russia. But prosecutions depend on evidence that can be presented in court, and on suspects who can be arrested. Officials directing a plot from abroad, like Yadav, are harder to reach: they are charged, but they remain outside US jurisdiction unless they travel to a country that will hand them over.
Other responses are diplomatic and defensive. The US State Department has publicly named transnational repression in its human rights reporting and in designations of foreign officials. Congress has held hearings and commissioned research, including the July 2026 Congressional Research Service brief that sets out the definitions and the policy options. Allies, including the UK, Canada and Australia, have raised the issue in their own parliaments and with the governments concerned. The challenge is that the tools of diplomacy, sanctions, public attribution and law enforcement, have to be weighed against the wider relationship with the country involved, which is often a major trading partner or strategic ally.
Why the Gupta sentence matters
The sentence matters for three reasons. First, it is a concrete penalty: 235 months in a US federal prison for a man who believed, in the words of the US Attorney, that he was beyond the reach of a US court while operating from India. Second, it establishes the facts in a court of law. Gupta pleaded guilty, so the plot, the recruitment, the 15,000-dollar payment and the involvement of an Indian government employee are matters of record, not just allegation. Third, it sets a marker for the other cases. The Nijjar killing in Canada remains unresolved in court, and other alleged plots are still being investigated. The message from the Manhattan courtroom is that the United States will treat an assassination plot on its soil as a grave crime, whoever directed it, and that the sentence will reflect that.
For the people the practice targets, the sentence is welcome but not sufficient. A single conviction does not stop a government from trying again, and it does not protect the next activist, journalist or lawyer who speaks out from exile. What it does show is that transnational repression has a name, that it is recognised as a distinct threat by the FBI, Congress and the courts, and that those who carry it out can end up in prison for a very long time.