Duterte Spokesman Ordered to Explain Bias Remarks

The Philippines' Senate impeachment court has ordered the spokesperson of Vice President Sara Duterte to explain why he should not be held in contempt, after he publicly accused several senator-judges of bias during her trial.
Presiding Officer Francis "Chiz" Escudero approved the show-cause order on Friday, the 45th day of Duterte's impeachment trial, after Senator-Judge Erwin Tulfo moved for it without objection. The clerk of court was directed to serve the order on lawyer Paolo Panelo, who was named Duterte's spokesperson in September.
Remarks that triggered the order
Panelo had told reporters on Thursday that senator-judges were acting like prosecutors when they questioned defence witness Rainer Dela Fuente, a former Anti-Money Laundering Council official. He named Senators Risa Hontiveros, Francis Pangilinan and Raffy Tulfo, saying their questions were aimed at destroying the witness's credibility.
"What we noticed is that those trying to break his credibility are our senator-judges. On that point alone, I think that's improper," Panelo said. He argued that testing a witness's credibility was the prosecution's job, not the court's, and urged Escudero to remind senator-judges to exercise restraint and remain impartial.
Tulfo raised the remarks at the start of Friday's proceedings, questioning why the vice president's spokesperson was publicly attacking the credibility of the senator-judges while Duterte is standing trial. "You are the spokesperson of the vice president now on trial here, and then you make comments against the senator-judges of the impeachment court," he said. "It appears there is a lack of respect for the impeachment court."
What the order does and does not mean
Escudero explained that the court's sub judice rule, Rule 18, does not directly cover Panelo because he is neither a lawyer of record, a witness nor a party to the proceedings. But he said Panelo could still be held accountable under Rule 71 of the Rules of Court, which governs contempt proceedings and applies to the impeachment trial.
The order gives Panelo an opportunity to explain his remarks. It does not constitute a finding of contempt, and no punishment has been decided. Panelo has said he will respond formally within the prescribed period once he receives the order.
He has also pushed back on free-speech grounds, saying his comments were fair, made in good faith and constitutionally protected. In a statement he cited Supreme Court rulings recognising the right of citizens to scrutinise and criticise public officials, including members of the judiciary, among them a 2012 ruling in Garcia, Jr. v. Manrique and an April 2026 ruling in Tolentino v. Heydarian, which warned courts to be wary of using contempt powers to suppress critical speech on matters of significant public interest.
Trial continues over wealth allegations
The dispute arose as the defence continued presenting evidence against allegations of at least 817.87 million pesos in unexplained wealth attributed to Duterte under Article II of the impeachment complaint. Dela Fuente was testifying as the defence sought to show that Cale88 Foods Corporation, a declared business interest of the vice president's husband, is a legitimate exporter.
Panelo's stance contrasted with that of defence panel spokesperson Michael Poa, who said on Thursday that senator-judges have the right to ask questions and express their views. The trial continues, with the court now waiting on Panelo's written explanation before deciding whether any further action is warranted.
Source: Philippine News Agency | Source: Philippine Daily Post