The Daily Byte
Breaking
Welcome to The Daily Byte — real stories from across Pakistan.
Saturday, 21 November 2026 · Pakistan

The Daily Byte

Stories from Pakistan that deserve to be heard
Minor National

FBR Proposes Faceless Tax Appeals With Hidden Officers

By The Daily Byte ·21 Nov 2026 ·3 min read
FBR House, the Federal Board of Revenue headquarters in Islamabad

The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has proposed a faceless system for income tax appeals under which taxpayers would never meet, or even know the identity of, the commissioner deciding their case, with hearings held by video link and voices digitally disguised.

The FBR issued draft amendments to the Income Tax Rules, 2002, through SRO 2136(I)/2026 on Wednesday, proposing a new Chapter XIXA covering Faceless Appeals. The proposed amendments have been issued under Section 237 of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001. The FBR has invited public objections and suggestions within three days of the notification's publication in the official Gazette, and the framework will take effect on dates separately notified by the FBR in the Gazette.

The draft is not yet final. Until it is formally notified, the existing appeal process remains unchanged, and the proposal is best read as the FBR's plan for how tax disputes would be handled, rather than a system already in force.

How the system would work

Under the proposed framework, an Appeals Wing will operate under the administrative control of the Member (Legal) Inland Revenue. A separate appeals wing will be established in Islamabad, comprising appellate units each headed by a Commissioner (Appeals).

Appeals submitted through the Iris e-portal will receive unique identification numbers and be allocated randomly through an automated system. All notices, evidence, written submissions, stay applications and rejoinders will be processed digitally, eliminating routine physical appearances. Taxpayers may also request decisions based entirely on written submissions, and dedicated e-hearing facilities will be available for those without internet access.

Anonymity at every step

A key feature is strict anonymity. Under proposed Rules 245D and 245I, the identities of appellate officers and Commissioners (Appeals) will remain concealed from taxpayers, their representatives and the tax department itself. During video-conference hearings, commissioners' faces will be hidden and their voices digitally modulated.

Officers previously involved in a case's audit, assessment or quality control will not be permitted to hear its appeal. Final orders will not display commissioners' names, designations or signatures. Instead, notices and decisions will carry system-generated Digital Identification Numbers for authentication and tracking.

Safeguards and limits

The draft also provides safeguards for technical failures of the Iris portal, allowing delays caused by Board-confirmed outages to qualify for condonation. Pending appeals will continue under existing procedures unless transferred electronically by the Board.

The option to appeal directly to the Appellate Tribunal under Section 127 of the Income Tax Ordinance would not change. The FBR says the change is intended to improve transparency and reduce direct contact between taxpayers and tax officials, as part of its broader push to digitise tax administration.

What happens next depends on the consultation. Affected parties have three days from the Gazette publication of the draft to lodge objections or suggestions, after which the FBR must decide whether to notify the rules as drafted, amend them, or drop them. Until that notification appears, no taxpayer will have their appeal heard under the faceless system.