FCCP Quashes NAB Case Against Shahzad Saleem

The Federal Constitutional Court of Pakistan (FCCP) has declared illegal the charge sheet and departmental inquiry against National Accountability Bureau (NAB) Director General Shahzad Saleem, ruling that matters already examined by the Supreme Court cannot be reopened after two decades without new evidence or legal justification.
A two-member bench comprising Justice Syed Hasan Azhar Rizvi and Justice Muhammad Karim Khan Agha announced the detailed judgment on Monday, 16 November 2026. The court also set aside a 12 May 2026 judgment of the Islamabad High Court in the same matter.
What the court decided
The bench declared the charge sheet and statement of allegations issued on 10 October 2024, along with all subsequent departmental proceedings against Saleem, null and void. The proceedings had questioned the legality of his appointment and promotions within NAB, and the authenticity of his academic degree.
The court drew a clear line between an appointment made in violation of the rules and misconduct by an employee. It held that a breach of recruitment rules alone could not amount to misconduct unless the officer had secured the appointment through fraud, misrepresentation, concealment of facts or corruption. No such finding had been made against Saleem.
Two decades on, no new evidence
At the heart of the judgment was delay. Saleem was absorbed into NAB in 2003, and questions about his appointment, qualifications and promotions had already been examined by the Supreme Court. The FCCP observed that NAB later questioned the same degree and opened disciplinary proceedings without presenting any new evidence or reasonable justification.
Reopening settled matters after such a long gap, the court held, was legally unjustified. The detailed judgment follows a short order issued by the same court on 16 October, when it allowed Saleem's appeal and brought the inquiry into his appointment to an end.
A case with a long history
The dispute has moved through the courts for months. Earlier this year the FCCP declined to stay the inquiry while it heard the appeal, directing the federal government to respond within three weeks. Saleem had first challenged a show-cause notice before the Islamabad High Court; after that petition was dismissed, he appealed to the Federal Constitutional Court.
His lawyer argued during the proceedings that NAB had launched the inquiry after an unexplained delay of nine years, and that the matter had already been decided by the Supreme Court. Justice Rizvi questioned why the bureau had failed to investigate the appointment during the intervening years. The NAB prosecutor conceded that the delay in starting the inquiry was attributable to the bureau, while maintaining that documentary evidence suggested irregularities in the appointment.
What happens next
With the charge sheet quashed and the proceedings declared void, the disciplinary case against Saleem is closed unless the judgment itself is challenged. The ruling also sets a wider marker for public-sector cases: old appointments cannot be reopened as misconduct proceedings simply because the rules were not followed at the time, without proof of dishonesty and without fresh evidence.
Read the original report: APP via Tez Khabar and Sun News.