Huntingdon train attacker 'not intent on murder'

Anthony Williams did not leave his house "intent on cold-blooded murder" when he stabbed 10 passengers on a moving train, his defence barrister has told jurors at Cambridge Crown Court, as closing speeches in the case laid bare the central question for the jury: did a man in the grip of psychosis intend to kill?
Williams, 33, of Langford Road, Peterborough, denies 10 counts of attempted murder relating to the attack on a Doncaster to London King's Cross service that was forced to make an unscheduled stop at Huntingdon in Cambridgeshire on 1 November last year. He also denies four further counts of attempted murder in connection with earlier attacks in his home city and in London.
The court has been told there is no dispute that Williams carried out the attacks. Jurors have been told he has admitted 12 counts of wounding with intent and two counts of attempting to wound. The issue they must decide is whether he intended to kill the people named in the 14 attempted murder counts.
Defence: a man in acute psychosis
In her closing speech, defence barrister Gillian Jones KC described Williams as a "man with a chaotic and disordered mind". She told jurors he had a delusional belief that his life was at risk because of a "conspiracy by the devil", and said his actions were those of a man "in the clutches of an acute psychotic episode".
Jones asked the jury whether Williams intended "to kill each of the individuals named in those 14 counts" or whether "in the throes of a psychosis and a delusional belief that he was in danger, he struck out". She reminded them that the prosecution had to make them sure that Williams intended to kill.
She said Williams "has accepted that he intended or attempted to cause really serious bodily harm", but added: "He did not simply leave his house... as a man intent on cold-blooded murder."
Jones pointed to what she said Williams did not do. "Look at what he didn't do... look where he did not attack even when an opportunity presented itself," she told the jury. She noted that Williams got on a train on 31 October, where she said "there's absolutely no attack at all". One witness on that train texted the British Transport Police, later saying he was "seemingly in his own world, detached from reality".
Jurors have heard Williams had been drinking alcohol, and Jones suggested he was "trying to get away from voices, drinking alcohol to try to dumb them down". The court has heard that experts agreed Williams was suffering from acute psychosis as a result of his schizophrenia, and that he had contacted his GP on 30 September to report that his medication was not working. His defence said he had stopped taking the antipsychotic quetiapine three days before the attacks because he believed it was ineffective, and that the voices then became worse.
Prosecution: deadly intention
Prosecutor Christopher Paxton KC told the court in his closing speech that Williams had "deadly intention". He said: "The fists and feet of this big powerful man as he was described were not weapons enough."
Paxton told jurors Williams had said "You're all going to die today" and "I'm not going to leave anyone" during the attack, and argued: "A psychotic intention to kill is still an intention to kill." He told the jury: "It was an existential threat to him as he saw it... hence why he had to kill them in his mind - me or them?"
As well as the 10 people on the train, prosecutors allege that on 31 October Williams tried to kill three people in Peterborough. He is also charged with attempting to murder a teenager in the early hours of 1 November on a DLR train in east London.
Williams has not given evidence in the trial. The judge, Mr Justice Calver, has told the jury not to hold that against him.
Jury to decide on intent
The trial continues, with the jury now considering whether Williams intended to kill. The case turns on a distinction the court has returned to throughout the trial: the attacks themselves are admitted, but attempted murder requires proof of an intention to kill, and the defence says psychosis and delusion robbed Williams of that settled intent.
Whatever the jury concludes, the admitted wounding counts alone mean Williams faces a substantial custodial sentence. The verdicts will decide whether he is also convicted of attempted murder on any of the 14 counts.