NAB Questions Plea Against NAB Appeals Shift to FCC

The National Accountability Bureau has questioned whether a petition challenging the transfer of NAB appeals to the Federal Constitutional Court can even be heard, as the Islamabad High Court took up the case on Friday.
Justice Umair Majeed Malik heard the constitutional petition filed by the Judicial Activism Panel through its counsel, Muhammad Azhar Siddique. The petition challenges an amendment to Section 32-A of the National Accountability Ordinance, 1999, under which second appeals in NAB cases, after decisions by the high courts, were shifted from the Supreme Court to the Federal Constitutional Court.
The court sought arguments from NAB on the maintainability of the petition at the next hearing and adjourned the proceedings without fixing a date for further hearing.
During the hearing, Advocate Shahid Khokhar appeared for the petitioner and told the court that senior counsel Azhar Siddique was in Lahore. He requested a short adjournment, which the court granted. The judge observed that a person challenging a law carried a heavy responsibility.
Who has replied to the petition
The National Assembly, the Senate and NAB have submitted their replies to the petition. NAB Prosecutor Rafi Maqsood, Additional Attorney General Rashid Hafeez and an assistant attorney general were also present at the hearing.
The petition argues that the constitutional jurisdiction of the Supreme Court cannot be taken away through ordinary legislation. Its counsel has contended that under Article 185 of the Constitution, appeals in NAB cases after a high court judgment lie before the Supreme Court, while the Federal Constitutional Court was established under Article 175F to deal with constitutional matters.
The law behind the dispute
The jurisdictional change follows amendments to the NAB law introduced on 5 March 2026, which inserted Section 32-A into the National Accountability Ordinance. The provision gives a person convicted in a NAB case, or the prosecutor general accountability on the direction of the NAB chairman, the right to file a second appeal before the Federal Constitutional Court within 30 days of a high court decision under Section 32.
In July, the Supreme Court ruled that the Federal Constitutional Court had exclusive jurisdiction over criminal appeals and pending petitions under the accountability law. A three-member bench held that the Supreme Court had no jurisdiction to take cognisance of NAB cases under Article 175F(a) of the Constitution, read with Sections 32 and 32-A of the ordinance, and that pending criminal petitions and appeals stood transferred to the new court by operation of law.
The Islamabad High Court had earlier issued notices to the federation, the secretaries of the National Assembly and the Senate, the law ministry secretary and other respondents on the same petition, and had also issued a notice to the attorney general to assist the court, since legislation enacted by parliament had been challenged.
The court will announce the next hearing date separately. Until then, the question of whether the challenge to Section 32-A is maintainable remains open, and with it the question of which court finally hears appeals in accountability cases.