Pakistan's 27th Constitutional Amendment Explained: Courts, Army Chief and What Changed

Pakistan's 27th Constitutional Amendment is the far-reaching set of changes to the country's Constitution that became law on 13 November 2025. It created a new Federal Constitutional Court, rewrote the rules for the command of the armed forces, changed how senior judges are transferred, and opened the way for a review of the balance of powers and money between the federation and the provinces. A year on, the new court has marked its first anniversary and is hearing constitutional cases that once went to the Supreme Court.
The amendment was pushed through Parliament in five days, passed by two-thirds majorities in both houses, and signed by the President on the same day the Senate gave its final approval. It has been praised by the government as long-overdue reform and condemned by critics — including Amnesty International, the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan and bar councils — as a blow to judicial independence. This explainer sets out what the amendment actually changed, how it was passed, and what it means a year later.
How was the 27th Amendment passed?
The federal cabinet approved the draft Bill on 8 November 2025. On the same day, Law Minister Azam Nazir Tarar presented the Constitution (27th Amendment) Bill, 2025 in the Senate, and it was sent to a joint meeting of the Senate and National Assembly standing committees on law and justice. The committees approved it on 9 November, and the Senate passed it the next day amid a walkout by opposition parties.
The Bill was presented in the National Assembly on 11 November and passed on 12 November with eight changes, by 234 votes in the 336-member lower house — comfortably above the two-thirds majority a constitutional amendment requires. Because the Assembly had amended the Bill, it returned to the Senate, which approved the revised version on 13 November by 64 votes to four. President Asif Ali Zardari gave his assent later that day, and the amendment became part of the Constitution.
The speed of the process drew heavy criticism. Amnesty International noted that the Act became law five days after the draft was introduced, and the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan publicly deplored the haste. Two senior judges of the Supreme Court resigned on the day the Act became law, and a third resigned days later, in protest at the changes.
What is the Federal Constitutional Court?
The centrepiece of the amendment is the creation of the Federal Constitutional Court (FCC), a new apex court that takes over constitutional cases from the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court's constitutional benches were abolished, and the new court now hears cases about the interpretation of the Constitution, disputes between the federal government and the provinces, and appeals from the high courts that raise constitutional questions. The Supreme Court continues to hear other appeals and retains its remaining jurisdiction.
The new court also takes over the power to act on its own initiative — the suo motu jurisdiction under Article 184(3) of the Constitution — which had historically belonged to the Supreme Court. The amendment says the FCC can exercise suo motu powers on petition, a change its critics say curbs the judiciary's ability to act on its own motion.
Justice Aminuddin Khan was sworn in as the first Chief Justice of the Federal Constitutional Court on 14 November 2025, the day after the amendment became law. Judges of the new court retire at 68, three years later than Supreme Court judges, and its chief justice serves a three-year term. The court formally began hearing cases on 17 November 2025, initially from premises at the Islamabad High Court on Constitution Avenue. Its first anniversary was marked on 13 November 2026, when the chief justice said the court had disposed of 9,000 cases in its first year.
The amendment also changed the definition of the Chief Justice of Pakistan: the title now belongs to the senior of the two chief justices — the chief justice of the Federal Constitutional Court and the chief justice of the Supreme Court. Justice Yahya Afridi remains Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, a post he has held since October 2024, with his three-year term expected to run until October 2027.
What changed in the command of the armed forces?
The amendment rewrote Article 243 of the Constitution, which governs the federal government's control of the armed forces. It abolished the post of Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Committee with effect from 27 November 2025, and replaced it with the office of Chief of Defence Forces, held by the Chief of the Army Staff, with broader responsibilities across the services.
The amendment also gives lifetime rank, privileges and status to officers who hold the most senior military titles — Field Marshal of the Army, Marshal of the Air Force and Admiral of the Fleet. Critics, including Amnesty International, say the amendment insulates the president and the heads of the armed forces from accountability; the government has presented the changes as a rationalisation of the command structure.
What changed for judges?
The amendment restructured the process for appointing and transferring High Court judges. The Judicial Commission of Pakistan now has a central role in supervising transfers, and the president and prime minister have a greater say in appointing the first chief justice and initial judges of the Federal Constitutional Court — a change Amnesty International says increases executive influence over the judiciary.
The transfer mechanism is one of the most contested parts of the amendment. A High Court judge who refuses a transfer can be required to explain the refusal, and if the Judicial Commission rejects that explanation, the judge can be compulsorily retired. Critics describe this as a mechanism that undermines security of tenure; supporters say it gives the system a way to move judges where they are needed.
The amendment also changed the composition rules for provincial cabinets, raising the minimum size for smaller provinces from 11 per cent to 13 per cent of the strength of the provincial assembly.
What about the provinces and the NFC Award?
The amendment also touched federal-provincial relations. It provides for a review of the distribution of federal revenue among the provinces through the National Finance Commission (NFC) Award, and for the possible transfer of certain subjects — including education and population planning — from the provinces back to the federation. These are subjects that were devolved to the provinces under the 18th Amendment in 2010, so any move to reclaim them is politically sensitive, and the amendment's provisions in this area are framed as a review rather than an immediate transfer.
Why is the amendment so controversial?
The amendment followed the 26th Amendment of October 2024, which had already changed how the Chief Justice of Pakistan is chosen — through a special parliamentary committee picking from the three most senior Supreme Court judges. Critics say the 27th Amendment goes further, fragmenting the apex court, shifting constitutional cases to a court whose first judges were appointed with heavy executive involvement, and weakening the security of tenure of High Court judges.
Amnesty International's statement of 5 January 2026 said the amendment "poses a grave threat to the independence of the judiciary and the rule of law in Pakistan" by creating a Federal Constitutional Court that lacks independence, eroding judges' security of tenure, and insulating senior office-holders from accountability. The Human Rights Commission of Pakistan and lawyers' bodies raised similar concerns, and the resignations of senior judges on the day the law was passed became the most visible symbol of the controversy.
The government and its supporters argue the opposite: that a dedicated constitutional court will clear the backlog of constitutional cases faster — the court's claim of 9,000 cases disposed of in its first year is presented as evidence of that — and that the changes to the defence command structure bring Pakistan's military leadership in line with modern practice. They also point out that the amendment was passed with the required two-thirds majorities in both houses of Parliament.
What does the 27th Amendment mean for ordinary Pakistanis?
For most people, the practical effect is about where constitutional questions are decided. If a case turns on the interpretation of the Constitution, or on a dispute between the federal government and a province, it now goes to the Federal Constitutional Court rather than the Supreme Court. Fundamental rights cases that raise constitutional questions also fall within the new court's remit.
The amendment does not change the ordinary criminal or civil courts, and it does not change the law that applies to everyday disputes. Its effects are structural: they concern who decides the biggest constitutional questions, who commands the armed forces, and how the federation and the provinces share power and money. Those are the questions that will shape Pakistani politics and law for years — and the debate over whether the amendment strengthened or weakened the country's institutions is still running a year after it became law.
Frequently asked questions
When did the 27th Amendment become law? It was passed by the Senate on 13 November 2025 and received presidential assent the same day.
Is the Supreme Court of Pakistan abolished? No. The Supreme Court continues to exist and hear appeals, but constitutional cases — including disputes between the federation and the provinces — now go to the new Federal Constitutional Court.
Who is the Chief Justice of the Federal Constitutional Court? Justice Aminuddin Khan, sworn in as the court's first chief justice on 14 November 2025.
What happened to the Chairman Joint Chiefs of Staff Committee? The post was abolished with effect from 27 November 2025, and the Chief of the Army Staff now also holds the office of Chief of Defence Forces.
Did judges resign over the amendment? Yes. Two senior Supreme Court judges resigned on the day the Act became law, and a third resigned days later, in protest at the changes.
Sources: Dawn, NA stamps approval on 27th Amendment; Wikipedia, Twenty-seventh Amendment to the Constitution of Pakistan; Amnesty International, Pakistan: Twenty-Seventh Constitutional Amendment (5 January 2026).