Pakistan Denies Backing Anti-Taliban Groups

The Taliban authorities in Afghanistan have accused Pakistan of supporting armed Afghan groups opposed to their rule, an accusation Islamabad firmly denies, according to a report published by DW on Friday.
Taliban Foreign Minister Amir Khan Muttaqi recently alleged that Pakistan had launched a “project to destabilize Afghanistan”, claiming that “thousands of armed individuals have gathered along the Durand Line [Afghanistan-Pakistan border] to undermine the stability achieved in Afghanistan”.
The accusations follow months of border clashes between Afghan Taliban and Pakistani forces. In July, the Afghanistan Freedom Front, an anti-Taliban group, reportedly clashed with Taliban forces in the Zebak district of Badakhshan, a north-eastern Afghan province. The group said it also carried out attacks in Nooristan and Kunar provinces in October, while another resistance group, the United Front of Afghanistan, claimed an attack on Taliban forces in Kandahar province, along the border with Pakistan.
Taliban spokesperson Zabihullah Mujahid alleged in an interview with DW’s Pashto-Dari service in September that fighters who created insecurity in Badakhshan had crossed from Chitral in Pakistan and later fled back there. “They had been brought in. Even Pakistani military personnel were with them,” he claimed. Pakistan’s Ministry of Information swiftly dismissed the allegations as propaganda.
Experts split over the claims
Groups opposed to Taliban rule say they are not supported by any external force and that their resistance is purely indigenous. But analysts interviewed by DW disagreed over how far Islamabad may be involved.
Shinkai Karokhail, a former Afghan lawmaker, told DW it would be logistically difficult for anti-Taliban Afghan groups to cross the Pakistani border and enter Afghanistan without Islamabad’s support. “It is simply impossible,” she said.
Afrasiab Khattak, a Pakistani political analyst and former senator, believes Pakistani support for anti-Taliban groups is “real”. “Taliban opponents come to Islamabad, hold meetings, and it is a part of Pakistan’s policy toward Afghanistan,” he told DW.
Qandil Abbas, an associate professor of politics and international relations at Quaid-i-Azam University in Islamabad, disagreed. “Pakistan may provide political support [to Taliban opponents], but not military support,” she said.
Ali Ahmad Jalali, a professor at the Near East South Asia Center for Strategic Studies at the National Defense University in Washington DC, said it was possible Islamabad was backing opponents of the Taliban as “leverage”. “When such incidents take place along the Afghanistan-Pakistan border, and given Pakistan’s history of support for Afghan groups, it would not be surprising if Pakistan is supporting these groups,” he said. He added, however, that he did not believe Pakistan was seeking to remove the Taliban from power, and that Islamabad’s objective was instead to pressure the Taliban into cooperating against the Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP).
Counter-accusations from Islamabad
Pakistani officials have repeatedly demanded that the Taliban take action against anti-Pakistan militant groups, particularly the TTP, a group responsible for attacking Pakistani civilians and soldiers, and the Baloch Liberation Army, an outlawed armed separatist group active in western Balochistan. Islamabad alleges these groups organise and launch attacks on Pakistan from Afghan territory with Taliban support.
Pakistan has also categorically rejected the Taliban’s claims about Badakhshan. Its Ministry of Information said in a statement in August: “Nothing can be farther than this from the truth. No credible evidence has been presented to substantiate this false narrative.” The ministry said the violence in Badakhshan reflected Afghanistan’s own internal security and governance challenges, not Pakistani interference.
Foreign Minister Ishaq Dar said this week at the Economic Cooperation Organization summit in Islamabad: “Meaningful progress requires Afghan authorities to address legitimate security concerns of neighboring countries, particularly the threat of terrorism.” Pakistan said on Friday that Afghanistan was not invited to the ECO gathering because Pakistan does not recognise the Taliban regime in Kabul.
No independent evidence has been presented to substantiate the Taliban’s claims of Pakistani military involvement, and the competing accusations underline how far relations between the two former allies have deteriorated since the Taliban returned to power in Kabul.