Scotland Orders Independent Review of NHS Grampian

The Scottish Government has ordered an urgent independent review of liver surgery at NHS Grampian, after a whistleblower surgeon revealed that a 2022 expert report had identified 19 avoidable deaths at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary.
Health Secretary Angela Constance announced the review on Saturday 21 November, following discussion with First Minister John Swinney. It will examine how concerns about hepatobiliary surgery, the surgery of the liver, pancreas and bile ducts, were handled by both the health board and the Scottish Government, including the unpublished 2022 report into the deaths of patients who underwent the surgery.
The whistleblower, Dr Mohammed Habib, a surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, went public on Thursday. He said he had raised concerns about patient safety repeatedly over a number of years, contacting the Scottish Government on four separate occasions, as well as going to the police and the Lord Advocate. He said he was prepared to put his career on the line to demand accountability, and has called for the health board to face a corporate homicide investigation. He also said two people had died after having the wrong procedure performed on them.
Dr Habib said he had been told the Scottish Government had no jurisdiction to investigate whistleblowing and individual health boards. Mr Swinney has said he first heard of three letters sent to him by Dr Habib on Thursday, and has ordered a separate review of how the Government handles correspondence.
What the review will examine
Ms Constance said the review would establish who knew what, when they knew it, what action was taken and why. It will also scrutinise the role of ministers and whether they were given adequate information and advice, as well as identifying any missed opportunities, unreasonable delays and weaknesses in accountability or governance.
The review will be led by someone fully independent of both NHS Grampian and the Scottish Government, with the lead reviewer responsible for determining the final terms of reference. Its findings will be published, and any evidence suggesting a risk to patient safety, potential criminality, serious professional misconduct or the need for urgent statutory action will be referred promptly to the appropriate body.
Ms Constance said: “Patient safety and high-quality care must always be the first concern of all those who work in, and with, the NHS. My thoughts are with anyone who has lost a loved one and I am acutely aware of the courage it has taken Dr Habib to come forward.” She added that patients and staff in Grampian had the right to expect full transparency and independent assurance that valid concerns are properly and robustly pursued.
She is expected to make a statement to the Scottish Parliament on Tuesday, setting out the timetable and announcing who will head the review. The Scottish Government has also moved to protect potentially relevant records: at the request of the First Minister, the Permanent Secretary issued an instruction to officials on Friday 20 November to preserve documents and information which could be required by the review.
Police inquiry and reaction
Police Scotland and prosecutors have confirmed they are investigating claims relating to the deaths. Detective Superintendent Carron McKellar said: “We received a report in 2024 following several deaths. Enquiries are being carried out, and a situational report will be submitted to the Procurator Fiscal.”
NHS Grampian chief executive Laura Skaife-Knight welcomed the review, saying there must be confidence that the concerns raised between 2012 and 2026 were investigated properly, that the findings were acted upon appropriately and that the necessary learning took place. She said the board would co-operate fully and take immediate steps to secure and preserve relevant information, files and records. NHS Grampian has set up a helpline for patients with questions, on 08085 202030.
Opposition parties welcomed the announcement but pressed for answers about who knew what and when. Scottish Labour deputy leader Jackie Baillie said the review must establish that, including for senior Scottish Government ministers, NHS bosses and civil servants who may have known and not passed on crucial information. Scottish Liberal Democrat MSP Yi-pei Chou Turvey said grieving families must be told everything that went on, while Scottish Greens health spokesperson Kayleigh Kinross-O’Neill said the inquiry was a welcome step toward getting answers and holding those responsible accountable.
The announcement follows a critical report last week from Healthcare Improvement Scotland, the watchdog, which identified serious weaknesses in leadership and management of the medical workforce across the acute sector of NHS Grampian. Scotland’s patient safety commissioner has also said she is not confident the board is getting to grips with the situation.