Sindh Bans Nov 29 Rallies Amid PPP-MQM Row

The Sindh government will not allow any political party to hold a rally on 29 November, after a provincial cabinet meeting at which Senior Minister Sharjeel Inam Memon accused the Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan (MQM-P) of planning to stir unrest in the province.
Memon said the government had received "some indications" of a plan to trigger riots, but he did not share specific evidence. He said a nationalist party and the MQM-P had both announced demonstrations at the same place on 29 November, raising fears of a confrontation, and that the government would take all necessary measures to maintain law and order.
"We are not afraid of MQM-P, nor have we ever been," Memon said at a press conference after the cabinet meeting on Thursday. "MQM-P has prepared a conspiracy to trigger riots, and we have some indications in this regard." He said the provincial administration would respond to any such attempt and would not allow anyone to disrupt peace in the province.
Committee to contact the parties
Memon said a four-member committee of Nisar Khuhro, Waqar Mehdi, Nasir Hussain Shah and Zia Lanjar would contact the parties. He said the government had urged the MQM-P and nationalist parties to postpone their planned activities, and that the formation of new provinces should be debated and decided in parliament rather than through street demonstrations.
The minister also questioned the legitimacy of the MQM-P's electoral mandate, alleging that it had secured support through unfair means and did not enjoy the backing of Karachi's residents. He defended the Pakistan Peoples Party's approach, saying the party had never supported violence or resorted to armed struggle. "PPP has never practised violent politics, nor has the party ever picked up weapons," he said.
MQM-P demands court action over Bilawal's remarks
MQM-P chairman Khalid Maqbool Siddiqui said PPP chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari's warning of bloodshed over the division of Sindh was a threat to the country and called for the courts to take suo motu notice. He asked why a nationwide debate on new provinces should raise the prospect of violence in Karachi, Hyderabad and Mirpurkhas, and characterised Bilawal's remarks as a threat to an entire community.
Siddiqui said the people of urban Sindh were "not anyone's serfs" and "not slaves", accusing the PPP of denying the province's cities a fair say in public spending and administration. He claimed Karachi generated 97 per cent of Sindh's revenue, a figure he did not substantiate in the speech, and called on the Sindh government to account for its spending, including funds received through the National Finance Commission.
He said the MQM-P had never called for a province exclusively for Karachi or for the Muhajir community, and that the party wanted new provinces wherever population growth and administrative needs justified them. The MQM-P has also renewed its demand for Chief Minister Murad Ali Shah to resign, blaming his government for poor governance and accusing PPP figures of diverting Karachi's water to tankers.
The referendum row behind the clash
The row follows weeks of argument over creating new provinces. Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi said on 12 November that surveys showed most people favoured new provinces and that the question should go to a referendum. Bilawal rejected that route, warning that a forced division of Sindh would lead to bloodshed in Karachi and Hyderabad, and said the constitution already lays down the procedure for changing provincial boundaries.
Senior MQM-P leader Farooq Sattar has separately called for a nationwide referendum in December under Article 48(6) of the Constitution, while MQM-P leader Mustafa Kamal has said a referendum on new provinces will be held and called December a crucial month. Under Article 239 of the Constitution, any amendment changing Sindh's boundaries would require a two-thirds majority of the total membership of each house of Parliament and a two-thirds majority of the Sindh Assembly.
The committee's contacts with the parties are the next step, with no party permitted to rally on 29 November. The Jeay Sindh Rahbar Committee's separate march in Karachi on 22 November is a different event, organised by a different committee, and is going ahead as planned. The photograph with this article is a portrait of MQM-P chairman Khalid Maqbool Siddiqui, not of the press conference.