Barristers Must Stop Using Rape Myths in Trials, Justice Secretary Says

Barristers must stop using rape myths to defend their clients in court, the Justice Secretary has said, warning that those who do so could face disciplinary action including being barred from practice.
Alex Norris has written to the Bar Standards Board (BSB), the body that supervises barristers, calling for new rules to prevent the use of rape myths in trials. The intervention follows the trial of Russell Brand, whose defence team was accused of deploying a series of rape myths during proceedings at Southwark Crown Court.
In his letter, Mr Norris said it was “unacceptable” for the profession to “perpetuate myths” about victims in court. He wrote: “(The board) must send a strong signal to the profession on the harm arising from rape myths, and that the perpetuation of such myths within a court room is unacceptable, just as they are unacceptable in our society at large.”
What happened in the Brand trial
Brand, 51, was convicted on 5 November of one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault involving four women, and was sentenced on 9 November to ten years and six months in prison. In his closing speech, his defence barrister, Ian Winter KC, questioned why his client’s accusers had not fought back, and the defence argued that they should not be believed because they had not screamed, kicked out or fled when they were attacked.
Mr Norris has called on the BSB to establish specialist standards for barristers representing defendants accused of rape and sexual offences, and has asked to meet Christopher Bones, the board’s chair, to discuss his concerns. Those who flout the rules could face disciplinary action, including being barred from practice.
Regulator and profession respond
A spokesperson for the BSB said the board agreed with the government that rape and sexual assault cases “must be decided on the basis of the evidence and not prejudice”. The board said it had set up an expert reference group this year to advise on strengthening standards for barristers acting in rape and serious sexual offence cases.
The Bar Council, which represents barristers, said a defendant denying a rape charge had a right to have the evidence against them tested in court, and stressed the importance of the BSB remaining independent of the government. Its chair, Kirsty Brimelow KC, is part of the group examining the need for further training.
A spokesperson for the Ministry of Justice said: “Rape myths have absolutely no place in our courts.” The intervention comes as the government reviews how rape trials are conducted, and follows a separate warning from Lord Burnett last week about the use of rape-myth directions in court.