Police search failings likely led to Stoke dad's death

An inquest jury has found that shortcomings in a police search probably contributed to the death of a father of two who was later found dead in a hospital car park lift.
Dwayne Nicklin, 28, from Blurton in Stoke-on-Trent, died from hanging at Royal Stoke University Hospital in December 2023. The jury reached its conclusions on Tuesday, 17 November, after hearing that officers searched the hospital site in the early hours of 28 December but never checked the lift where he was found.
The jury found that Mr Nicklin’s hanging was a deliberate act, but it could not determine whether he had intended to take his own life.
What the jury found
Jurors concluded that there had been poor communication between the officers involved in the search, and an over-reliance on uncorroborated CCTV footage. They found that the shortcomings “probably contributed more than minimally to the death”.
The jury also found that Mr Nicklin was still alive when two officers searched the multi-storey car park at around 1.30am, and that if a more thorough search had been carried out, it was likely police would have found him and been able to intervene, using powers under the Mental Health Act to take him to a place of safety.
The two officers searched different areas of the car park, including the stairwells, but neither search included the lift. The inquest heard there were no CCTV cameras covering the lift. Mr Nicklin was found in the lift at around 8am by a member of hospital staff arriving for work. He was pronounced dead at 8.03am.
A call for help in the night
Mr Nicklin had been diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder and emotionally unstable personality disorder, and had a history of self-harm and suicidal thoughts. He was under the care of the Sutherland Centre, which provides mental health services in Dresden, during 2023. He had lost his job at the start of the year and faced a relationship breakdown and homelessness.
In the early hours of 28 December, he video-called his former partner and said he was by a car park near Harplands Hospital. She called 999 shortly after 1am, after he appeared to be attempting to hang himself. Police were dispatched to Harplands Hospital within two minutes, with the first officers arriving at 1.21am.
Officers first searched the grounds of the mental health hospital, then moved on to the nearby Royal Stoke site. Before 2am, Mr Nicklin called his former partner again and said he was in a lift at the hospital. Officers believed he might be in the hospital’s Lyme Building, an area he had frequented while working as a security guard at the hospital. Hospital security staff checked CCTV and believed they had sighted him in the building some time before 3am.
Six officers took part in the search. At around 3am, officers at the scene asked for Mr Nicklin to be classed as a high-risk missing person, but the request was refused and he remained graded as a concern for safety. Chief Inspector Emily Butterworth, the force incident manager that night, told the inquest that Mr Nicklin had been disclosing his location in order for someone to help him, and that finding him at the earliest opportunity was the priority.
Area Coroner Daniel Howe offered his condolences to Mr Nicklin’s family at the end of the hearing.
Anyone affected by the issues in this story can call Samaritans free at any time on 116 123.