Gwent officers sacked over St Mellons crash lies

Two Gwent Police officers have been sacked after a misconduct panel found they lied about searching for two missing young women who had been involved in a fatal car crash in Cardiff.
PC Richard Hardwick, 32, and PC Lauren Livingstone, 27, were dismissed without notice after being found to have committed gross misconduct over their handling of missing person reports made on the day of the crash in St Mellons in March 2023.
The panel, which concluded at Rodney Parade in Newport on Friday, found the officers had failed to carry out searches at the homes of Eve Smith and Sophie Russon, and then lied about having done so. Their actions were described as "deliberate and misleading", and the panel said their conduct may have compromised the investigation.
The crash that left three dead
The case stems from a crash in the early hours of Saturday 4 March 2023, when a Volkswagen Tiguan carrying five young people came off the A48 in St Mellons and ended up in woodland. The car and its occupants were not found for 46 hours.
Three of the five people in the car died: Eve Smith, 21, Rafel Jeanne, 24, and Darcy Ross, 21. Sophie Russon and Shane Loughlin were seriously injured and survived.
The three women were reported missing by their families at around 7.20pm on 4 March, after a night out in Newport the previous evening. Hardwick and Livingstone were sent to the family homes to gather information and search for clues about where the women might be.
The panel heard the officers visited the addresses on the night of 4 March but did not search them, a point made by Sophie's father Nathan Russon, Eve's mother Emma Borg and Eve's brother Zaine Smith. Hardwick took the lead at Sophie's address, while Livingstone took the lead at Eve's.
Searches recorded but never carried out
Panel chair Ian Arundale concluded that no search had taken place at either address. He said the bulk of the evidence suggested no house search had taken place, and pointed to the absence of evidence from the former officers about the circumstances of the homes.
Hardwick faced six allegations, including that he lied about searching the homes of the crash victims and that he also lied to his supervising officer and to the police watchdog. Four of the allegations against him were found proven and two were found proven in part.
Livingstone faced four allegations, including that she lied about searching the two houses, made a dishonest entry on the investigation log and lied to her supervising officer. All four allegations against her were found proven.
Mr Arundale said Hardwick knew a search had to be done and stated on the form that it had been. "He was dishonest," he said. Of Livingstone's log entry, he said filling out the form as she did was "a deliberate act that misled".
Stephen Morley, the barrister for Gwent Police's professional standards department, had called for both officers to be sacked, saying their behaviour involved the "fabrication of evidence in an ongoing missing persons inquiry".
Dismissed without notice
In dismissing the pair, Mr Arundale said there was "high culpability, high harm, and high aggravating factors", with limited mitigation. He took into account the previous good character of both officers, but said the matter was too serious for them to receive a final written warning. He said their actions had led to the "integrity of a missing persons investigation being compromised".
The Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC), which investigated Gwent Police's response to the missing person reports, described the officers' actions as "inexcusable". IOPC director of engagement Derrick Campbell said both officers had failed "in the fundamental basics of policing; to act honestly and with integrity".
Mr Campbell said Hardwick had deliberately lied on police records and to his supervisor, and that Livingstone had ample opportunity to tell the IOPC the searches had not been conducted.
Chief Superintendent John Davies of Gwent Police said the force's thoughts remained with everyone affected, and that it mattered the case had been investigated independently.
More hearings to follow
Two more Gwent Police officers are due to face misconduct hearings over their handling of missing person reports linked to the crash. After a lengthy IOPC investigation, the watchdog said in 2025 that six officers, including Livingstone and Hardwick, should face disciplinary proceedings. Sergeant Matt Jones and former PC Gareth Murphy are still to appear before a panel, while two other officers were dealt with internally earlier this year.
The panel heard the failure to search the homes may not have changed the outcome for the people in the crashed car, but recording searches that never happened undermined the investigation and public trust in policing.
Sources: WalesOnline | The National Wales