High Court dismisses Betfair duty of care claim

London's High Court has dismissed a lawsuit brought against Betfair by the family of a man who took his own life, rejecting their argument that the gambling company owed him a duty of care.
The family of Luke Ashton, 40, who died by suicide in April 2021, alleged that Betfair encouraged him to gamble and that this worsened a gambling disorder, causing or materially contributing to his death. Betfair denied the claims.
Mr Justice Swift dismissed the case on Friday, 13 November, ruling that the duty of care proposed by the family did not arise. The judgment, in Ashton v TSE Malta LP [2026] EWHC 2935 (KB), is a closely watched decision for the gambling industry.
Why the claim failed
The judge held that a gambling operator's duty of care to prevent psychiatric injury is narrow and does not incorporate the Gambling Commission's regulatory standards. He found the duty is limited to acting to prevent gambling disorder in its severe form where that is foreseeable.
The ruling said: "There is no sufficient evidence to support the conclusion that Mr Ashton did suffer from gambling disorder and that being so, no possible basis on which the requirement for foreseeability could be met."
Because Mr Ashton had never been diagnosed with a gambling disorder, the court found the duty never arose, and it did not need to decide breach, causation or contributory fault.
The judge found that the broad duty contended for by the family was materially the same as the duty rejected in an earlier case, Calvert v William Hill Credit Ltd [2008] EWHC 454 (Ch). He also attached significance to section 24(8) of the Gambling Act 2005, which provides that breach of the Gambling Commission's code does not of itself give rise to civil liability.
The case against Betfair
The family sued TSE Malta, the holding company for Flutter, which owns the Betfair, Paddy Power and Sportsbet brands, alleging negligence by the betting firm. The claim was brought under the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1934 and the Fatal Accidents Act 1976.
At a hearing in June, lawyers for Ashton's widow, Annie Ashton, argued that Betfair created or perpetuated the risk of harm through actions "including the design and operation of an addictive gambling product and the provision of inducements and free bets".
The court heard that Ashton had gambled thousands of pounds and lost substantial sums. Court filings stated that he lost £21,777 over a three-year period. In messages left for his wife and children before his death, he said his "mental health (was) all over the place" and that "gambling was just the straw that broke the camel's back".
The family was seeking £846,478 in damages, including gambling losses and the income Ashton would likely have provided to his family.
A coroner's inquest in 2023 concluded that Ashton suffered from gambling addiction and found that more interaction from Betfair may have been appropriate.
Reaction and wider context
Betfair argued that previous English court rulings had found gambling operators owed no "general duty to protect problem gamblers from the consequences of their actions".
"While we welcome the court's ruling, this is a tragic case and we once again offer our sincere condolences to Mrs Ashton and her family," a Flutter UKI spokesperson said.
The case was seen as a landmark test of whether a betting company could be held liable for a customer's death, and the first UK case in which a court was asked to find that an operator owed a duty of care to customers showing signs of problem gambling.
Britain's gambling industry has faced growing calls for higher taxes and tighter regulation to tackle addiction, as betting has become more widespread and easier to access through smartphones. Finance minister John Healey last month announced an increase in Machine Games Duty, a tax on the net takings from some slot machines, in his annual budget.
Gambling companies warned ahead of the budget that higher taxes could lead to job losses in a sector already dealing with tax increases announced last year.