HMRC's Sweeping Powers: AI Chats and Tax After Death

HMRC is set to gain sweeping new powers to demand taxpayers’ AI chatbot histories and to chase tax records decades after a person’s death, under changes added to the Finance Bill following Chancellor John Healey’s Autumn Budget.
The measures, which survived the Bill’s first reading on 3 November, widen HMRC’s information-gathering powers as the government seeks to close a tax gap that cost the Treasury nearly £60 billion in lost receipts in 2024/25.
Tax advisers say the new wording is wide enough to make AI chatbot conversations used in preparing a tax return legally compellable — including prompt histories and full chats on tools such as ChatGPT, Microsoft Copilot and Claude. Third parties, including the AI companies themselves, could be ordered to supply the data.
AI chatbot histories could be demanded
The changes rewrite HMRC’s Schedule 36 information powers, which allow the tax authority to demand documents and information to check whether the correct tax has been paid. Under the proposed rules, the definition of what can be demanded would expand from computer “records” to any “relevant” digital material — a change advisers say could capture chatbot conversations that played any part in calculating the figures on a return.
HMRC insists it is modernising old powers for a digital world and that requests will still need a lawful basis. “It is not about going through everyone’s use of large language models,” the tax authority has said. “We can only request information where we already have a lawful basis to do so.”
Failure to respond to a Schedule 36 information notice already carries an initial penalty of £300, and the wider package introduces a statutory “Duty to Correct” regime from April 2028, legally requiring taxpayers to fix mistakes on old tax returns once they become aware of them.
Under that regime, an inaccuracy — even if unintentional — could be treated as “deliberate”, the highest penalty tier HMRC uses when it believes false figures were supplied or information withheld. That carries a fine of up to 100 per cent of the unpaid tax and a scrutiny period of up to 20 years. At present, a mistake discovered after filing is treated as “careless”, carrying a lower penalty of up to 30 per cent over six years.
Families could be asked for records decades after a death
Under the same package, HMRC would be able to demand information from the families of deceased taxpayers more than four years after their death, with no ultimate time limit, as long as a tax tribunal approves the request. At present, the tax authority can demand information from bereaved families for up to four years after a death, covering inheritance tax, capital gains tax and income tax.
Executors would not have to be told before the tribunal makes its decision, according to the Telegraph, which first reported the plans. Critics warn the change could leave executors digging out old paperwork long after an estate has been settled, dragging grieving relatives back into financial uncertainty.
An unlimited period for requesting information would not, by itself, mean HMRC could recover unpaid tax indefinitely — separate deadlines apply to tax assessments. An HMRC source told the newspaper the change was intended to help Britain share information with overseas tax authorities that have longer assessment periods.
Shadow chief secretary to the Treasury Richard Fuller criticised the proposals, warning that investigations years after a death could drag families back into financial uncertainty “when they should be allowed to grieve”.
Bank accounts and homes also in the package
From July 2029, HMRC would gain the power to recover lower-value tax debts directly from the bank accounts of people who repeatedly fail to engage — a move previously announced in the Budget. The tax authority already has some debt-recovery powers, but only in limited circumstances and following a face-to-face meeting.
HMRC inspectors would also be able to photograph homes without permission to check whether they could be hit by the new property tax on homes worth £2 million or more, due to take effect in April 2028. Inspectors can take pictures from public roads, but must have permission to enter a property or its grounds.
The powers are not yet law. The Finance Bill 2026-27 still needs to pass Parliament, with Royal Assent expected by mid-2027, and the government says the changes bring existing powers into line with international standards and reflect how tax information is now stored digitally.
Source: The Scottish Sun