Isla's Principles: New Cancer Guidance for Young Patients

New guidance to help GPs spot cancer in young people sooner has been published in Scotland, named Isla’s Principles in memory of a teenager whose concerns were dismissed for years before her death.
Isla Sneddon, from Airdrie, died in March 2025 aged 17, six months after being diagnosed with advanced breast cancer. She first found a lump in her breast in July 2022, when she was 15. Her parents, Mark and Michelle Sneddon, say her concerns were initially dismissed as hormonal, and a later urgent referral was downgraded because of her age.
The guidance was published by the Centre for Sustainable Delivery (CfSD) as a Programme for Government commitment. It supports existing good practice on assessing and referring children and young people with suspected cancer, and sets out four key actions for clinicians to consider when a young patient presents with unexplained, persistent symptoms.
The four principles
The principles spell out the acronym ISLA. I stands for intuition: a clinician’s instinct can be an important part of professional judgement and should be acknowledged and respected when reviewing referrals where cancer is suspected.
S stands for share information clearly, with open communication about ongoing concerns and diagnostic uncertainty between primary and secondary care, even while a patient waits for specialist review. L stands for look again at the patient, looking beyond the obvious when symptoms persist, evolve, recur or do not fit the expected clinical picture. A stands for agree a safety-netting plan, so that the young person and their family understand the next steps, including when and how to seek further help.
Repeated visits should raise suspicion
Under the guidance, repeated visits to healthcare services and persistent concerns raised by patients and their families should raise a GP’s suspicion of cancer. Patients should leave every appointment knowing what to expect next and when to seek further help.
Phil Hodkinson, CfSD’s Co-Clinical Lead for Earlier Diagnosis, said: “Isla’s Principles are a reminder of the importance of listening carefully, openly communicating clinical uncertainty, and taking a fresh look when symptoms persist or do not fit the expected pattern.”
Dr Sal Peterson, Co-Chair of the Scottish Primary Care Cancer Group, said the principles were an important addition to existing guidance, highlighting “the importance of GP intuition, especially in people with vague symptoms”.
A family’s campaign for lasting change
Isla’s parents welcomed the guidance and said they hoped it would create lasting change. “We cannot change what happened to Isla but knowing that her legacy could help another child to receive the investigations, diagnosis and treatment they need sooner gives us a purpose to keep going,” they said.
“Our hope is that Isla’s Principles become more than guidance on a piece of paper. We want them to create lasting change in how children and young people with concerning symptoms are listened to, investigated, and referred.”
The family petitioned the Scottish Government for change after Isla’s death, attracting 43,000 signatures, and have raised thousands of pounds for young people receiving treatment at The Beatson West of Scotland Cancer Centre.
Health Secretary Angela Constance said: “This guidance has been developed to support earlier and more accurate diagnosis of cancers in children and young people. Many clinicians already adopt the ethos of Isla’s Principles but it is important this is applied consistently across Scotland.”
“This will ensure that every young person presenting with worrying symptoms has a voice in their care and is given clear guidance over how they will be supported through a diagnosis,” she added.
Sources
Scottish Government: Isla’s Principles
Glasgow News: Airdrie family welcomes new cancer guidance for GPs