The Daily Byte
Breaking
Welcome to The Daily Byte — real stories from across Pakistan.
Saturday, 21 November 2026 · Pakistan

The Daily Byte

Stories from Pakistan that deserve to be heard
Minor UK News

Jury rules Carlisle police shooting was lawful

By The Daily Byte ·21 Nov 2026 ·4 min read
Borland Avenue in Carlisle, where Sergii Kuzmenko was shot by police in December 2022

An inquest jury has ruled that the police shooting of a man who held a knife to a child's throat in Carlisle was a lawful killing.

Sergii Kuzmenko was shot seven times by two Cumbria Police firearms officers at a house on Borland Avenue in Carlisle on 19 December 2022. A full jury inquest into his death began on Monday, 9 November, at Cumbria Coroner's Court in Workington and concluded on Friday.

Police had been called to the house in the Botcherby area of the city after an emergency call reporting a man who was drunk and making threats to kill. The call was made by Mr Kuzmenko's sister, Luidmyla Hedley.

When officers entered the house, they found Mr Kuzmenko holding a child with a knife at their throat. Despite the presence of uniformed officers and a threat of taser deployment, he refused to put the knife down and threatened to cut the child's throat, the inquest heard.

Seven shots in seconds

Uniformed officers were unable to get Mr Kuzmenko to drop the knife or release the child, and firearms officers were called to the scene. They arrived several minutes later.

Body-worn camera footage shown to the jury showed an armed officer, identified in court only as Officer C, entering the house at 3.51pm. He fired the first shot two seconds later, and another six shots were fired in the next eight seconds. Officer C fired six shots in total, while a second officer, Officer L, fired one.

As the two armed officers entered the house, Mr Kuzmenko was still defiant and continued to hold the knife to the child's throat, the inquest heard. In accordance with their firearms training, both officers independently made the decision to discharge their weapons. Several shots were fired until the child was released.

Mr Kuzmenko was pronounced dead at the scene by paramedics, who arrived a few minutes later. The child survived. A second child and a woman were also brought out of the property.

Evidence heard by the jury

Officer C told the inquest he "absolutely" thought Mr Kuzmenko was going to stab the child. He said he had been a firearms officer for seven years before the incident but had never fired a live round at a suspect before.

Officer L said he shouted at Mr Kuzmenko to put the knife down three times and expected him either to drop it or let go of the child, but neither happened. He said he had been an armed police officer for four years and completed about 120 hours of firearms training each year.

Home Office pathologist Dr Alison Armour told the inquest there were knife marks on the girl's neck and her injuries would have been unsurvivable if more pressure had been applied, with the child potentially dead within a minute. Vital blood vessels were just millimetres away from the knife marks, she said.

The jury also heard that bodycam footage showed Mr Kuzmenko dropped the knife after the third shot, but the officers fired three more times. Officer C told the inquest he believed the child's life was still at risk, having not seen the knife fall from Mr Kuzmenko's hand. Asked by counsel to the inquest Joseph Hart if he would have taken shots four, five and six if he had seen the knife drop, the officer replied: "Absolutely not."

Leila Benyounes, barrister for Mr Kuzmenko's family, told the hearing: "Something very much went wrong in this case. Two officers fired shots that were unnecessary." Officer L disagreed, saying: "I always believed that Sergii was going to kill that child."

A reopened inquest

Senior coroner Kirsty Gomersal reopened Mr Kuzmenko's inquest and told the jury there would be an examination of the use of firearms and police policy for interacting with people whose first language is not English. Mr Kuzmenko was Ukrainian and spoke limited English.

The two armed officers who shot Mr Kuzmenko, along with two other armed colleagues, were granted anonymity at a previous hearing, on the basis their safety could be at risk if their identities were revealed.

The inquest, which had been expected to last up to three weeks, concluded on Friday with the jury's finding of lawful killing.