Migrant groups prepare legal challenge to ILR rules

Two groups representing migrant workers are preparing legal challenges to the government's earned settlement reforms, arguing that the longer wait for settlement should not be applied retrospectively to people already living and working in the UK. The moves follow the Home Office's publication of its final earned settlement policy on 2 November 2026.
The Skilled Worker Justice Alliance has announced it is advancing preparations for a potential judicial review of the reforms. In a public statement, it called on the Home Office to preserve the existing five-year pathway to settlement for Skilled Worker visa holders who entered or switched into the route before 12 May 2025, and their dependants, subject to the salary requirements and transitional provisions under the previous rules. That date marks the publication of the government's immigration white paper setting out plans to reform settlement.
Separately, the Skill Migrants Alliance says it has raised £25,000, instructed public law counsel, and is preparing a formal pre-action protocol letter ahead of a potential High Court judicial review. It is urging the Home Office to extend the protections recently given to care and healthcare workers to all existing Skilled Worker visa holders facing a doubled 10-year wait for indefinite leave to remain.
What the reforms change
Under the framework set out in the government response, A Fairer Pathway to Settlement (CP 1707), the standard qualifying period for settlement, also called indefinite leave to remain, will rise from five years to 10 years. Faster routes remain: three years for the highest earners on at least £125,141 a year, and five years for higher earners on at least £50,271, eligible public service workers and people with a recognised British connection. A 20-year route applies where immigration breaches or reliance on specified public funds prevent an earlier pathway. The standard English requirement will rise to B2, and the separate 10-year Long Residence route will close.
The consultation received 204,667 responses. Crucially, this is announced policy, not yet law: the Immigration Rules have not been amended, no start date has been published, and the Home Secretary has said the changes will begin to be laid from the December Immigration Rules and be implemented over the course of 2027. Until the rules are laid, the current rules still apply.
The legal arguments
The Skilled Worker Justice Alliance said it does not oppose the government's authority to introduce prospective reforms, but objects to retrospectively changing settlement conditions for people who made employment, family and financial decisions in reliance on the previously published five-year framework. It said the principal legal issues under consideration are substantive retrospectivity, legitimate expectation and procedural unfairness, and that it is seeking independent preliminary advice from a King's Counsel specialising in public law. Any decision to pursue legal action would depend on that advice, the evidence, the timing and content of government decisions, and sufficient funding.
The Skill Migrants Alliance, which says it has instructed Kingsley Napley and barrister Sonali Naik KC, welcomed the protections that preserved the five-year route for nurses, doctors, teachers and roughly 280,000 pre-May 2025 care workers and dependants earning at least £25,000, and argues the same fairness should apply to other existing skilled workers.
This article is general information, not immigration advice. Immigration rules change, so check the official page on GOV.UK before making plans, or speak to a regulated immigration adviser. Sources: Electronic Immigration Network and GOV.UK, A Fairer Pathway to Settlement. Also reported by The News Intel.