MPs Urge Fraud Probe Into Failed Insulation Scheme

MPs have urged the government to refer its failed home insulation programme to the Serious Fraud Office, after a report found more than 30,000 homes left with defects.
The Public Accounts Committee said the National Audit Office had found that 98 per cent of external wall insulation and 29 per cent of internal wall insulation installed under the Energy Company Obligation 4 and the Great British Insulation Scheme up to mid-January 2025 was defective. Some faults, including damp and mould, posed immediate risks to health and safety.
Fraud fears behind the referral call
The committee said the likely role of fraud in the poor-quality work was a key reason for its recommendation. Energy regulator Ofgem estimated that businesses had falsified claims for installations in up to 16,500 homes, and MPs said the true figure was probably much higher.
Committee chair Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown said a 98 per cent failure rate was the most catastrophic fiasco he had seen in 12 years on the committee, adding that the project had been doomed to failure from the start.
Households still waiting for repairs
Ministers have said no household should have to pay to fix the damage, but the report warns that families have no real assurance of that. The original installer is liable, with up to £20,000 covered by guarantee if it fails or stops trading, yet the committee is aware of cases where damage was worth more than £250,000.
By mid-September 2025, nearly a year after the problems emerged, less than 10 per cent of the estimated 30,000 affected homes had been found and fixed. The report calls on the government to scale up its find-and-fix programme, deliver it far faster, and ensure the new Warm Homes Plan does not repeat them.