The Daily Byte
Breaking
Welcome to The Daily Byte — real stories from across Pakistan.
Saturday, 21 November 2026 · Pakistan

The Daily Byte

Stories from Pakistan that deserve to be heard
Minor UK News

PIP shake-up may widen to all working ages

By The Daily Byte ·15 Nov 2026 ·4 min read
The black front door of 10 Downing Street in London, the official residence of the Prime Minister

Downing Street is considering whether a planned overhaul of disability benefits for under-25s should be extended to people of every working age, according to a report in the Guardian published on Friday.

The move would take a set of changes designed for young people and apply them across the whole working-age population. Ministers have spent this week discussing whether the idea of “participation first” — spending more on support to help people into work while cutting or removing some disability benefits — should apply to over-25s as well.

Prime Minister Andy Burnham and other cabinet ministers have examined the proposal, the Guardian reported. Either Mr Burnham or the Work and Pensions Secretary, Pat McFadden, could make the case publicly within weeks of two reviews being published: Alan Milburn’s review of youth unemployment and Stephen Timms’s review of disability benefits.

What the under-25s plan involves

The government is preparing to accept recommendations next week from its adviser Alan Milburn, the former Labour health secretary, on overhauling the benefits system for young people. Under his proposals, people under 25 would receive training and support instead of the health element of universal credit.

Young people with disabilities would also lose their personal independence payment, known as Pip, under the plan. They would instead be able to apply to a local fund for specific short-term expenses and equipment, rather than receiving an ongoing payment. Those with the most extreme needs who cannot work would have their entitlements protected.

Mr Milburn has told the Guardian that the support set out in his report would create 440,000 employment and education opportunities by 2036 and raise young people’s net incomes by more than £2bn. He said the main finding of his review was not a lack of ambition among young people but a lack of opportunities, adding that he had not met a single young person who wanted to be not in education, employment or training.

Why extending it would be contentious

Applying the same approach to older claimants would be politically risky. The previous prime minister, Sir Keir Starmer, faced a large rebellion from Labour MPs last year when he tried to push changes to health and disability benefits through Parliament, and was forced into a major U-turn.

Some government sources believe the idea of extending the changes to over-25s will ultimately not survive, given the probable backlash from parts of the Labour Party. Others believe Mr Milburn has successfully made the case that the system needs to change and that the public support his efforts.

Mr Burnham has repeatedly said the changes would not be “crude cuts”, but some backbenchers have said they are sceptical and worried about the effect on young disabled people. A government source said the support offer and benefit changes Mr Milburn had set out were “devised for young people and the specific circumstances they face”, but added that the Timms review had set out that Pip was “no longer fit for purpose”, and that the government would respond to that review when it reported.

Cost and charity concerns

Some estimates have put the cost of the support proposed by Mr Milburn at about £6bn, although it is understood the government will not spend at that level on the support provided to young people instead of benefits. There has also been concern within some government departments, including health and education, that the upfront funding for the extra support will come from within their budgets.

Charities have warned about the effect on young claimants. The Joseph Rowntree Foundation said the proposals could significantly weaken the safety net for hundreds of thousands of young people with a disability or health condition, leaving many of those on universal credit living on a basic rate of support of about £80 a week. Its senior policy adviser, Iain Porter, said cutting someone’s income when they were already struggling to afford food or the bus to college would make it harder for them to stay in education or find work.

More than 40 leading charities have warned ministers against tougher benefit sanctions or cuts for disabled young people, saying in a joint letter to Mr Milburn and Mr McFadden that such measures risked pushing thousands of vulnerable youngsters deeper into poverty and further away from employment.

Welfare spending has reached £333bn this year, with pensioners receiving roughly 55% of the budget and young people, including those not in education, employment or training but not children, accounting for about 2.5%.

A government spokesperson said: “The Milburn and Timms reviews are due to be published shortly, and we will respond to their recommendations in full. We will always ensure there is a safety net for the most vulnerable and those who are unable to work.”