Royal Mail Could Become Unviable Within Years, Former Business Secretary Peter Kyle Warns

The government must act urgently to put Royal Mail on a fair footing with its rivals, or the postal operator risks becoming unviable within a few years, former business secretary Peter Kyle has warned. Kyle, who held the business brief until July, said ministers had reached a decision point over whether they wanted Royal Mail to remain a working business in the years ahead.
Kyle said Royal Mail was being undercut by parcel delivery competitors that did not employ their staff on the same terms. Royal Mail's workforce is overwhelmingly made up of permanent employees, while some rivals rely heavily on self-employed couriers, a difference he argued distorted the market. According to Royal Mail, 98 per cent of its 130,000 workers are permanent employees, with rights to pensions, sick pay and holiday pay.
What Kyle says is driving the warning
Kyle said he had begun preparing officials at the Department for Business and Trade to examine the parcel delivery market shortly before he was replaced as business secretary by Jonathan Reynolds in July. The review he had in mind would have looked at where the costs in the market fell and where the profit was being made, and whether successful companies were upholding the values expected of business in Britain today.
He stressed that the review he planned would not have looked at changing Royal Mail's universal service obligations, or at altering the terms and conditions of its staff. The focus, he said, would have been on the structure of the parcel market itself. "If we leave it another few years then Royal Mail will just become unviable and it will just collapse under the weight of having full-time employees," he said, according to BBC News reporting.
Royal Mail has struggled in recent years with the long decline in letter volumes, growing competition in parcels, and fines from the regulator for missing delivery targets. The company is owned by International Distribution Services, and its performance has improved in recent months, but it is still falling short of its targets for first and second class post.
Government response: wait for Ofcom report
A government spokesperson said ministers would consider whether further reforms were needed in the parcel market once the regulator, Ofcom, publishes its annual monitoring report in December. The current business secretary met Royal Mail and the Communication Workers Union last week to press for timely progress on improving quality of service.
The department has also opened a consultation on tackling what it calls bogus self-employment, a practice it describes as businesses mislabelling staff as self-employed to avoid their statutory obligations. Royal Mail has welcomed the consultation, and a company spokesperson said parts of the delivery industry were driving a race to the bottom on employment standards. The company said it would continue to press for a level playing field, with strong and enforceable standards across the industry.
Ofcom agreed last year to scrap second class deliveries on Saturdays and to lower the target for delivering first class post within a day of collection to 90 per cent, after Royal Mail was fined £21 million in October 2025 for missing its delivery targets in 2024-25.
Reaction from MPs and the union
Pressure is also coming from the opposition benches and from the unions. Many MPs have reported large numbers of complaints from constituents about missed and delayed deliveries. Shadow business minister Bradley Thomas said customers were repeatedly being asked to pay higher prices while the service they received was not improving, and blamed Royal Mail's management rather than its postmen and women.
The Communication Workers Union, which represents postal workers, is pressing ministers for what its general secretary, Dave Ward, has described as a new model of ownership. Ministers have said they will wait for Ofcom's annual monitoring report in December before deciding whether further reforms are required, while the consultation on employment practices runs in parallel.
Frequently asked questions
Is Royal Mail about to collapse? No. Kyle warned it could become unviable in a few years if nothing changes; the company continues to trade and deliver. What does the government plan to do? Ministers say they will consider further reforms after Ofcom publishes its annual monitoring report in December.
Source: BBC News, 17 November 2026. A second report on the crisis talks, including owner Daniel Kretinsky's intervention and the 3 November meeting with the business secretary, was published by the London Stock Exchange news service on 15 November 2026.