Six Sindh Mayors Reject New Provinces Plan

The mayors of Sindh's six divisional headquarters have jointly rejected calls to carve new provinces out of Sindh, declaring at a press conference in Karachi on Friday, 20 November, that the province's geographical integrity is non-negotiable.
Karachi Mayor Murtaza Wahab, Sukkur Mayor and Sindh government spokesperson Arsalan Islam Shaikh, Hyderabad Mayor Kashif Shoro, Larkana Mayor Anwar Luhar, Nawabshah Mayor Qazi Rasheed Bhatti and Mirpurkhas Mayor Abdul Rauf Ghori were responding to recent remarks by MQM-Pakistan convener Khalid Maqbool Siddiqui on the creation of new provinces and administrative units.
The mayors said new provinces could only be created in accordance with Article 239(4) of the Constitution, and that Article 140A, which deals with the empowerment of local governments, had no connection with the formation of new provinces. Calls for a referendum on the matter, they said, amounted to a departure from the constitutional framework.
Apology demanded over culture remarks
The mayors also demanded an apology for what they described as mocking Sindh's culture and promoting ethnic politics. Mr Shaikh demanded the withdrawal of remarks comparing Sindhi culture to "the jungles of Africa", and said a petition under Article 199 would be filed against Mr Siddiqui over what he described as a distortion of constitutional provisions.
Mr Wahab said hatred was among the most damaging forces in any society, and that the Pakistan Peoples Party believed in bringing people together. He said Sindh had a history spanning 5,000 years and that Karachi's history did not begin in 1947, pointing to the shrine of Hazrat Abdullah Shah Ghazi in the city.
He recalled that Karachi was considered the jewel of the region in the 1970s, before ethnic politics in the 1980s divided communities and destroyed social harmony. Frequent shutter-down and wheel-jam strikes, extortion, kidnapping for ransom and terrorism became part of the city's past, he said, and a city once renowned for education, literature and culture saw the pen replaced by the gun.
Peace had been restored only after immense sacrifices by political workers, journalists and law enforcement personnel, Mr Wahab said, and Karachi must never return to the conditions of the 1980s and 1990s. He described himself as an Urdu-speaking Sindhi and said the people of Sindh wanted to remain united.
Swipe at MQM-P's internal divisions
Taking a swipe at the MQM-P, Mr Wahab questioned its internal unity, saying Mr Siddiqui's press conference had not even been attended by Mustafa Kamal, and that the political dispute had shifted from Nine Zero to Bahadurabad and Raees Amrohvi Road. A party divided by internal differences, he said, could hardly claim the authority to decide Sindh's future.
Mr Shaikh said the joint press conference was a response to remarks he described as contrary to facts, and argued that the mayors had been elected through public votes and therefore represented the people's mandate. He said "Karachi is not anyone's personal property", and warned that if the current approach continued, the mayors' next press conference could be held at Nine Zero alongside residents of Karachi's urban constituencies.
He said the PPP was not opposed in principle to creating new provinces where constitutional requirements were fulfilled and public grievances remained unaddressed, but insisted the same standards must apply to both Punjab and Sindh. He also alleged irregularities in the previous census, claiming around Rs40 billion had been spent on the exercise and that Karachi's urban population figures had been reduced after objections from the MQM.
Other mayors back the stance
Hyderabad Mayor Kashif Shoro said the seeds of hatred sown by the MQM among the public had continued to influence society for decades, but that people had become politically aware and would no longer tolerate further damage from ethnic and divisive politics. He said residents of different languages lived together peacefully in Hyderabad.
Larkana Mayor Anwar Luhar said Mr Siddiqui had made remarks about Larkana despite the MQM not having even a single councillor in the city, while Mirpurkhas Mayor Abdul Rauf Ghori said the people of Mirpurkhas had rejected the MQM in elections. At the end of the press conference, all six mayors reaffirmed their commitment to protecting Sindh's geographical integrity, constitutional supremacy, peace and brotherhood.