Second Speed Camera Fault May Have Let Drivers Escape Fines on England's Motorways
By aminah
·17 Nov 2026
·4 min read

Further problems with the accuracy of speed cameras on English roads have been uncovered which may have allowed thousands of drivers to slip through the cracks and escape fines, the BBC reported on Tuesday 17 November.
The Home Office has revoked the legal approval that allowed footage from the affected cameras to be used as evidence in legal proceedings. National Highways is now ending its contract with Verra Mobility, the US firm that operates the cameras, and ministers have warned that extra police patrols and mobile cameras are stepping in to enforce speed limits.
## What is the new fault?
Roads Minister Justin Madders confirmed that further joint testing with the Home Office uncovered a second potential activation issue in the variable speed camera system, originating from the same 2019 software upgrade behind the first fault.
"Ministers are not prepared to accept any scenario where there is a hypothetical risk some drivers could be prosecuted incorrectly, or that enforcement was in any way compromised," Mr Madders said.
The affected cameras cover variable speed sites on smart motorways, as well as the A14 between Huntingdon and Cambridge and its A1 approach junction. Automated speed enforcement has been halted on a limited stretch of England's motorway network while the issue is dealt with.
National Highways' modelling of the data has concluded that the probability of the specific operational circumstances that could result in this error occurring is no more than 0.1%, and there is no real-world evidence to suggest it has impacted enforcement. The Government said it is "considering all further commercial and legal options that may be appropriate".
## The first fault: 2,650 wrongful activations
The initial error was uncovered last year and affected 154 variable speed cameras across 22 police force areas, leading to thousands of drivers being wrongly fined after 2,650 erroneous activations between 2021 and 2025.
The fault was caused by a delay of around 10 seconds between a variable speed limit changing on overhead gantry signs and the cameras recognising the new limit, meaning some drivers were incorrectly detected as speeding after the limit had changed. National Highways said the 2,650 incidents represent fewer than two per day, compared with more than six million camera activations on the affected roads over the same period.
Affected drivers will be contacted directly by the relevant police force to be reimbursed and have points removed from their licence where relevant. Not all camera activations are enforced, so not all of the wrongful activations will have resulted in fines.
## What ministers said
"We can't take chances with this," Mr Madders told the BBC. "If we're going to prosecute people, we need to be confident the system is working as it should. That's why we've taken the action we have."
He admitted the camera system will not be fully fixed until sometime next year.
The Government said driver compliance remains at its usual high levels and the affected roads remain safe. National Highways has put in place further traffic officer patrols and is using existing CCTV cameras to monitor the network.
## The Westall Review
Alongside the announcement, the Department for Transport has published the Westall Review report, which examines how the original anomaly occurred and how it was handled, and identifies lessons for National Highways on governance, crisis management and data.
Mr Madders said: "The Government welcomes the report and accepts the recommendations it contains, and I would like to thank Tracy Westall for her thoroughness and dedication in conducting the review." National Highways has accepted the review's recommendations and has already begun to implement the improvements needed.
## What should drivers do?
Drivers should continue to observe the posted speed limits as normal, National Highways has said. Enforcement continues through mobile cameras and marked and unmarked police patrols while the fixed variable speed cameras are out of use as evidence. Anyone who believes they were wrongly fined should wait to be contacted by the relevant police force, which is reviewing cases.
## FAQ
**Which cameras are affected?**
Variable speed cameras on smart motorways in England, plus a section of the A14 between Huntingdon and Cambridge and the A1 approach junction to the A14.
**Can the footage still be used as evidence?**
No. The Home Office has revoked the approval that allowed the affected cameras' footage to be used as evidence in speeding cases.
**How many drivers were wrongly fined before?**
National Highways found 2,650 wrongful speed camera activations between 2021 and the end of 2025, caused by the first fault. Affected drivers are being contacted by police for refunds and points removal.
Source: [Fleet World — Second motorway speed camera 'anomaly' may have let drivers escape fines](https://fleetworld.co.uk/second-motorway-speed-camera-anomaly-may-have-let-drivers-escape-fines/). Second source: [BBC — Speed camera fault may have allowed drivers to escape fines](http://www.allusanewshub.com/2026/11/17/speed-camera-fault-may-have-allowed-drivers-to-escape-fines/).