UK Unprepared for Catastrophic Risks, Lords Warn

The Government appears “complacent” about the possibility of “catastrophic risks” facing the United Kingdom, and the country is underprepared, a cross-party committee of peers has warned. The House of Lords National Resilience Committee set out its findings on Monday in a 102-page report, Are we ready? Building a culture of resilience, following a nine-month inquiry.
The report says the world is more turbulent and insecure than it has been for decades, and warns that Britain is not ready for the threats that could follow — including AI-supercharged cyber attacks, sabotage and even war. It also says the public does not have a full picture of the level and frequency of so-called grey-zone attacks taking place.
Plans “largely out of date”
The peers said current resilience plans are largely out of date because they fail to prepare central government and local authorities for several crises happening at once — for example, a cyber attack combined with disruption to water supplies, a biological hazard and the physical collapse of critical infrastructure.
“We need to move fast to turn things around,” the committee warned. It called for a “radical shift in the mindset of both public and government”, adding: “Preparedness and resilience in the face of major national crises must be normalised and seen as part of everyday life.”
The committee also urged ministers to be more open with the public about the threats the country faces. “The Government should stop being squeamish about telling it straight to the public about the kind of threats we face,” the report said, adding that evidence suggests the public would reward honesty and openness “with trust and reassurance, not fear and alarm”.
Medicines, food and supply chains
The report highlights how dependent the UK has become on overseas supplies. The committee said it was “shocked” to discover that the UK imports 80 per cent of the active ingredient for penicillin antibiotics, and a large proportion of all other antibiotics, from China, and that the UK no longer has any domestic antibiotic manufacturing capacity of its own. “Indeed, there remains only one antibiotic manufacturer in the whole of Europe,” the report said.
Food supply is similarly concentrated: just nine retailers account for around 94.5 per cent of food sold through UK supermarkets. The peers said interruption to the supply chains of food, medicines and other items and services “is at the heart of what an up-to-date national resilience system needs to tackle, shifting from a ‘just-in-time’ approach to being ‘just-in-case’”.
The Government’s “Be Ready” campaign, launched last month to encourage every household to stock emergency supplies such as food, water and a wind-up radio, was described as a step in the right direction — but the committee said much more needed to be done, and quickly.
What the committee recommends
Among its recommendations, the committee called for a cabinet minister solely responsible for resilience, supported by a chief resilience officer at permanent secretary level, and an annual statement on resilience to Parliament by the prime minister. It also called for supply chains for critical products, including medicines, food and water, to be diversified.
The peers also recommended scrapping plans to switch off digital terrestrial television, warning that the move would weaken national resilience by reducing universal access to communication. Ministers are proposing to end free-to-air television as soon as 2034 and move services online, a change The Sun reported could affect an estimated eight million households whose televisions are not connected to the internet.
The report concludes: “Trust in central government is at a low ebb. But the government has already shown that it has the right ambition. What it needs now, before it is too late, is the leadership, the funding and the urgency to go with it.” Neither report quoted an immediate response from the Government.
Sources: Sky News: Government accused of ‘complacency’ over ‘catastrophic’ security risks to UK; The Sun: Burnham’s plans to end Freeview risks a communications blackout during a crisis, warns probe; UK Parliament: Publication of Committee Report — Are we ready? Building a culture of resilience (HL Paper 79).